preview

The Consolidated Life Case Study

Decent Essays

The consolidated Life case study

Main problem

The main problem in this case is the conflict between two different cultures underlined by two divergent management styles. A loose and people-oriented management style, applied by the supervisor Mike Wilson which proved to be efficient with the current situation of Consolidated Life company, versus a strict and task-oriented management style exercised by the senior vice president Jack Greely, a style assumed by the management to be the reference model that reflects the company’s culture and to be followed by all managers.

Clash of cultures and management styles

When Mike first got hired, the culture was “laissez faire” with flexible supervisory style, supervisors were free to …show more content…

Conflicting Values

Mike believes that the main value resides in achieving good results whatever are the means or the management style followed to realize these results. He is totally convinced that he is doing the right thing by realizing great results without the need to apply strict rules on his subordinates and this belief is clearly illustrated by the sign on this office’s door saying: “ Any fool can manage by rules. It takes an uncommon man to manage without any”. This sign representing an artifact reflecting his particular culture of doing things.

On the contrary, Jack believes that obeying to the company’s culture and management style is the key value in the company. Results should be achieved under the conformity of company’s style and procedures without any subjective interpretation from managers’ side.

Different Leadership styles

Mike shows a leadership style characterized by a free spirit, unorthodox, flexible management and people oriented. It is much like a country club management style focused a lot on people and a little on the rules.
It is a kind of supportive leadership being very friendly and approachable, showing a lot of concerns for status and needs of subordinates.

On the other hand, Jack’s leadership is characterized by being task-oriented, strict with rules enforcement. It is

Get Access