preview

Essay The Cultural Dilemma of Native Americans

Satisfactory Essays

| The Cultural Dilemma of Native Americans | | | The Cultural Dilemma of Native Americans In this painting by George Catlin titled “Assinneboine Chief before and after Civilization” it shows a very proud Assinneboine Chief standing straight and proud. His clothing expresses his Indian culture as he is dressed in leggings and shirt made of mountain goat skin, and finished with a pictured robe of buffalo hide over his right shoulder. Moccasins covered his feet and his tribal headdress decorated his head allowing his long hair to blend with the feathers of his headdress. In his left hand is his long pipe which he would smoke with those with whom he would want to make peace. The background which is painted in a lighter hue then …show more content…

Maybe the artist was trying to show that the Chief was more interested in material items now rather than his family or his tribe? The painting illustrates the artist’s rendering of what happened to Chief Wi-jún-jon when integrated into the white culture following a trip to Washington, DC in 1832. On this returning side you see no Indian heritage, it has been destroyed by civilization. The painting is a great view through the artist’s eyes and mind as to how he felt about the change which occurred with the Chief during his time. George Catlin truly honored and respected the Indians that he captured so elegantly in his paintings and I believe he felt saddened when Chief Wi-jún-jon returned to his native people looking and acting liking a white person. Mr. Catlin was there when the Chief returned to his native people and witnessed firsthand their unwillingness of them to accept his appearance as well as their slow acknowledgment in recognizing who they saw before them. The Chief must have been excited to share with his people all that he learned in the stylish world of their equals and was probably saddened by their initial responses. As he began to share his stories of occurrences that he encountered on his tour he was scorned and foreseen as a liar because his people could not imagine or comprehend what he had seen and lived. (Catlin) Catlin's message that he is

Get Access