preview

The Dangerous Myth Of Grade Inflation Summary

Good Essays
Open Document

In “The Dangerous Myth of Grade Inflation”, Alfie Kohn explores the phenomenon behind grade inflation. Whether it is complaints or just the general idea that such an undesired occurrence has routinely taken place, Kohn certainly explores them all. He begins with addressing that the issue has not just transpired, but has been in existence over time as many have complained periodically. As Kohn notes on page 261, grade inflation is recognized as a poor occurrence, yet Kohn reveals the struggle as “truly substantive issues surrounding grades and motivation have been obscured or ignored.” Why is this so? Kohn goes on to explore the issue through some evidence and research, but finds that while grades have become higher more recently than before, that still does not prove inflation exists behind the rise in grades (261). By this Kohn reveals a trend to the reader with the facts, or lackthereof, behind grade inflation.
The issues present are conflicting as Kohn explores further research and finds both …show more content…

However, he paints his sources in his favor and seemed to highlight his view and discredit grade inflation all too frequently. By including a source in which he completely discredits the subject of that source, he decreases the credibility in which he crafted this essay’s argument(s). Other than the words written, it is hard to say if he should be trusted as an authority with not knowing his background. However, yes, his words do seem feasible rather than far-fetched, even if he does craft the essay in his favor. I was persuaded to believe that grade inflation is a sham by the way Kohn crafted his arguments, but I also have some doubts due to the opposing evidence Kohn included. Previously I believed there was some truth to grade inflation, but Kohn does an efficient job of discrediting any previous complaints concerning the

Get Access