The Giver Book Comparison

For instance, in the book Joppy knew Albright; Albright knew Todd Carter; Todd Carter knew Richard McGee as well as Matthew Terrell whereas in the movie every character denied knowing each other except Albright and Joppy. Another noticeable difference is that in the book Frank Green, Daphne’s brother ends up murdered and in the movie he lives and they both end up moving. The third noticeable difference is a character name change from the book to the movie; Matthew Teran in the book is Matthew Terrell in the movie and he ends up being murdered in the book whereas at the end of the movie he’s running for mayor. A fourth noticeable difference is the pier scene. In the book Albright and Easy meet at the Santa Monica pier and in the movie it is the Malibu pier. And the last most noticeable difference between the book and the movie is that Mouse knows Daphne Monet or shall we call her by her real name Ruby Hanks; however, in the movie the audience never finds that out. In the movie the only true thing you get to know about Daphne is that she is both black and white. Therefore, due to the many differences between the book and the movie it is confusing to the audience since it is almost like dealing with two different stories because of the plot inconsistencies.

Normally, when a movie is made about a story in a book the two stories are not exactly the same. The movie is adjusted by adding small details or leaving out some parts in order to make the story more

The first difference that caught my eye was how there was no cat, in the book there was a cat named, Sammie, and Sammie always got stuck in one of Billy’s traps. But in the movie

For example, the reader is introduced to Helen as a baby. Meanwhile, in the motion picture the watcher is introduce to Helen when she’s six years old. This a major difference because the reader views how Helen started unlike the watcher of the movie. Another example, in the story Helen is pictured as a filthy mess, but in the film she is always in a nice set of clothes. This is a very important change because it shows how a person depicts Helen. Lastly, Annie is haunted by nightmares of her brother at the State Court house. In the book their is great deal of flashbacks in the story, but in the movie their is only one. This shows how Annie had to fight the voices in her head and the guilt of her “ killing” her brother. Even with these differences, it still tells the amazing story of Helen

Finally, the other similarity I discovered was when Johnny killed Bob. In the book, they went to where Dally was and Dally helped them by giving them his gun, jacket and money. Dally also told them where to hide and how to get there. (Hinton 53-56). The movie also portrays this scene very well. Again, this is only one of the many similarities in the book and movie.

Both share the same plot, and there are very little differences between the two. These are a few of the differences that I was able to notice between the book and the movie. There are several others throughout the story, but they are all just as minute and in the end they have no effect on the outcome of the story. Overall, I was very impressed with the movie and it was very true to the book. I have seen my share of movies that were adaptations from books that did not do the book justice, but this one is almost exactly like the book, so it was very

The Giver is both best-selling book by Lois Lowery and a major motion picture. They are both centered on the same storyline and character but also have some major differences. “The movie (and the book) takes place in the confines of “the community,” something that started after “the ruin,” when all memories were erased and everyone became equal.” (Krule, 2014). The book and the movie and the book are very different in many ways such as the plot, characters and concepts. The book and movie are more different than they are similar, although there are a few similarities.

In the movie, there is a border around the community, however, in the book, there is no border which is a really big thing. Why it’s important is because when Jonas passed the border memories went to everyone and so did the colors. No one had any colors except black, white, and grey. The reason he left is that he wanted to get Gabriel away from the community because they were going to release him.

One big difference was when Jonas went to the Givers home in the book he was let in by a woman maybe his secretary but in the movie there was a facial recognition procedure that allow him in. The movie is basically an advanced place filled with drones, 3D transmissions and impressive looking devices of all sorts. In the book it's not as advanced as the movie but it's still pretty impressive. The book The Giver has books in in it and the movie jonas has never saw a book in his life.

The book starts in the narrator’s hometown of Woking. While the movie starts in New Jersey. This is a huge change, not only does it affect where the story starts it affects where the characters travel and where they end up. Despite the difference in continents, both protagonists travel virtually the same distance and encounter many of the same things. An example is both characters are attacked trying to cross a river. In the movie this is the Hudson River, but due to the setting of the book it occurs on the River

One major difference was Rifka. In the movie they combine Gritl and herself. In the movie Rifka was her cousin. Tzipporah and Ruven were made into one person named, Sarah. There were lots of characters that were left out of the movie, like hannah brother, Aaron. Another difference was the Age. In the movie Hannah was sixteen years old, but in the book she was twelve. The Execution was different. In the movie the people who disobeyed the rules were hanged, but in the book they were shot when they were trying to escape the concentration

In the Devil’s Arithmetic there is a lot of similarities as well as differences. I think that the book was honestly better because it had more things going on with different characters. The book also wasn’t as emotional and heartbreaking to the reader as the movie was. The similarities of the book and the movie are mostly important things that happened.

On of the first things I would like to elaborate on the book Asher was a going to be assigned the Director or Recreations. Fiona was suppose to be the one who took care of the old. whereas in the movie they both don't get those roles. Fiona is taking care of babies. Asher is a Pilot . The movie is completely wrong in this part. Not only do I think the book fit their roles a little bit better

The Giver, a book by Lois Lowry, and The Giver, the movie version, have more differences than similarities. The movie changes some details to fit into the new themes and expectations of the film. There are some similarities between the two, such as the general idea of a community based off of Sameness and order. However, there are many differences in things like the themes, the plot, the symbols, and the characters that just cannot be neglected. The movie is more different to the book than similar because it removes important details, such as Jonas’ pale eyes, limiting exposure to themes like government surveillance, and changing the ending of the movie to being more literal.

Nick starts off as an adult in the novel, presumed to be 29 years old after it is revealed towards the end of the plot that it was “[his] birthday. [He] was thirty” (135).