preview

The Indian Civil Rights Act (ICRA)

Good Essays

Native Americans have been working unremittingly for sovereignty over their own affairs since the very beginning of Euro-American contact. The twentieth century in particular was a progressive time for Native Americans as they continued to fight for sovereignty over their own affairs and Historians have taken note of this. Most historians of Native Americans have given a substantial amount of attention to the Indian Civil Rights Act (ICRA). Many historians concur that the ICRA was a fundamental tool for Natives to not only gain autonomy in a progressively bellicose society, but equally between themselves. After acknowledging that Indian Nations were not invited to the Constitutional Convention and that the United States Constitution was never …show more content…

Because of this, the evidence has lead to multiple explanations and evaluations, which at times, are absolutely conflicting to each other. This paper contends that, due to the lenses in which some historians look to try and decipher the effectiveness of the ICRA, many have failed to adequately foreground that the ICRA is ineffective. These lenses have prompted some historians to go great lengths to fortify an earlier discernment of the ICRA as a constructive and progressive act whereas other historians go on to argue for a re-interpretation of the past all together. This paper will show how these various historians are in conversation with each other, but still fail to reach the same …show more content…

The ICRA helped create a conversation about the need for protection of individual rights not only from the federal government, but also tribal councils. This act also facilitated a bigger discussion that Native Americans were going to endure and combat any assimilation policies that the federal government purposed. During the nineteenth century, there was a heavy push by reformers to persuade the federal government to take an even more aggressive approach toward assimilating Native Americans. A prominent policy during the nineteenth century was allotment. At a basic level, allotment attempted to force Native Americans to assimilate. At the very foundation of allotment was the Dawes act which had an underlying assumption that Native Americans wanted to be farmers amongst other jobs that would help compulsorily usher Natives into the larger American society. Francis Prucha, for example, author of the book Americanizing the American Indians, takes a great deal of time in talking about the attitudes towards Indians and federal policy prior to the twentieth century. He relies heavily on the evidences of speeches, articles, and pamphlets written by reformers who worked diligently to sway federal Indian policy to forcibly assimilate Indians. In his book, Prucha submits that reformers had three main goals. The first goal focused on using allotment to break

Get Access