preview

The Lottery Video Analysis

Decent Essays

Is it possible for a student in public school to have a good education as much as in the charter school? It is not possible to have a good education, especially with the tenure system that makes it hard to fire a terrible teacher in public school and ruining the student educations, but charter school is different and the reason is that they had highly skilled teachers that can provide good education for a student. The main reason that charter schools can provide good education and can afford highly skilled teacher is the property value. Another reason that student has a bad education is the tenure system can cause teachers or professors in public school to lack the motivation to teach students and usually occur at their mid-year in their career. …show more content…

The main difference in public and charter schools has is the property value that can cause teachers with a good teaching skill to work in a charter school and poor performing teacher to work in public school. The video demonstrates, “The involvement of a public school in New York City called the school zone that is filled with ordinary students that did not have the chance to go to a charter school called the Harlem Success Academy and the main reason is students can only get enroll by being picked in the lottery.” (Lottery) Charter schools usually hold annual lotteries giving nearly four hundred students a chance to enroll between charter school and public school assign by the city. The video also demonstrate, “A good example of African American child called Christian Yoanson that was trying to get enrolled into Harlem Success Academy, but never got picked from the lottery and has to go to public school.” (Lottery) Another reason students go to public schools is parent with low income from their job that can make it difficult for their child to enroll into charter schools and can only enroll into public school. “Emil Francis Yoanson is a good example of a parent that has low income from his job and always wanted Christian Yoanson his only child to get enrolled into charter schools despite having a low income.”(Lottery) Hopefully charter school in New York City can change …show more content…

The system of the school has segregation of public schools and charter schools that is causing problem to students from public school. For instance a latest course case involving, “The Lawsuit, Vergara v. California aimed to strike down statues that make it difficult for administrators to dismiss poorly performing teachers, require layoffs based purely on seniority and allow for permanent employment status after eighteen month of teaching.” (Tillotson) A student that is attending at public school will no longer has to worry about teachers with poor teaching skills that can ruin the students’ education and their careers. Some teacher wanted to prevent this from happening and good example involving, “California teacher unions wanted to intervene and were a part of the Vergara v. California lawsuit case.” (Tillotson) The California teachers wanted to save the tenure system for their own benefits instead of thinking about the student benefits and ruining the student life. There were some people that wanted help the student like for example, “A court judge called Rolf M. Treu was in favor of the students and he found all the challenged statues are not constitutional about the tenure system.” (Tillotson) Rolf made it possible to have a better learning system and good teacher for students to learn in public school

Get Access