preview

The Melting Pot Video: Inclusive Or Exclusive?

Decent Essays

Inclusive or Exclusive?
At a very early age, kids are taught about the fundamentals of the great country of which they are a part of. Often children are shown Schoolhouse Rock videos to induce them to want to learn, for example, the “The Great American Melting Pot” video. The “Melting Pot” video attempts to teach children how different people with different cultures came to America and were able to mix. Even though the “Melting Pot” explains how a vast number of people with different cultures came together to be American, the song and the video do not coincide. The song lyrics would be considered Liberal Multiculturalism, while what the video itself portrays would be Conservative Multiculturalism, demonstrating how kids were being taught …show more content…

According to Kincheloe and Steinberg, Liberal Multiculturalism is the belief that people from different ethnicities “share more commonalities than differences” (p. 10). It is a belief that people are culturally invisible which is what is portrayed in the audio of the “Melting Pot” video. In addition, narratives can also go along with the audio of the video being an example of liberal multiculturalism. Barton and Levstik in “ The Story of National Freedom and Progress” demonstrate how throughout the years, America has “steadily expanded to include new groups of people” (p. 169). Narratives are slightly skewed under a certain belief which in this case for both the passage and the “Melting Pot” video is to convey that everyone is just a …show more content…

Regardless of the audio being about inclusiveness, the video animation does not follow that idea instead a feeling of exclusiveness appears. This then pulls as a constraint because the video does not demonstrate mixing of cultures instead it focuses on representing people with lighter skin. During 0:52-0:55 of the video Lady Liberty appears with a cookbook on the ingredients necessary for “The Great American Melting Pot” showing different ethnicities that make an American. The cookbook characterizes Africans as one single ethnicity as opposed to the Irish, Germans, Swedish, and Greeks are all separate in the cookbook? So why is it okay that Africa having 54 countries is put as one while Europe's counties are broken

Get Access