preview

The Modern Cartesian Subject And The Post-Modern Subject

Better Essays

Introduction:
Introduced by Renee Descartes, the subject was established and fore grounded after several stages of radical doubt and skepticism that decentralized nature and placed the individual subject above both the church and state ( Shorto, 2008). Therefore, as each of us experiences ourselves as subjects, we are still open to modern day external infringements. Unlike in the Middle Ages where existence was never questioned and “Gods divine plan was not itself a belief one could accept or reject. It was an entire way of life.”(Dreyfus and Kelly, 2011). This essay will highlight the difference between the Modern Cartesian Subject and the Post-Modern Subject, establish the two contexts the subjects arise from, highlight the key role of Renee …show more content…

Post Modernism as a philosophical and cultural movement rejects the entire philosophy of the Enlightenment project, which is where the Modern Cartesian subject finds itself, at the end of the scientific revolution. Therefore, it places itself in opposition to modernism and all its essential elements and its realization in the Enlightenment (Hicks, 2011). It is a reaction to Modernism and Modernity’s social and political failings (Sim, 2005).
It is characterized by discontinuity, plurality and the rejection of Meta narratives and all authority in its many guises, whilst attempting to remove the human individual from the center of the universe and critique rationalism (Ferry, 2010). The critical spirit of Modernity that is inextricably intertwined with science turned against Modernism and continued to away with any illusions on improving mankind or religious utopia (Ferry, 2010).
The Modern Cartesian Subject contrasted against the Subject of …show more content…

The Modern Cartesian subject puts forward that there is one universal rationality. This extreme emphasis on uniformity means that any reaction or barrier to the world view of Modernism was subjugated, resulting in the oppression of any difference or diversity (McGrath, 2004). An example would be religion within the secular framework of modernity, which became confined to the private. This framework can be perceived as oppressive for devote religious people, although to an extent religion triumphs under the conditions of modernity as it continues to exist. However, it exists only as a prisoner of modernity without any superiority. Thus the Modern Cartesian Subject can be found to be a political problem, as it believes it contains the ultimate definition of what it means to be a free human being. This over confidence in human reason, centralization of man is intolerant to all other views and grand visions of emancipation in Liberalism, Democracy and other political perspectives of the modern era are too totalizing and neglect the oppression of individuals and disparate groups. This is exactly what Post-Modernism reacts against, the intolerance and constant mastery of the other into the same. Post-Modernism accepts the other, there is no privileged civilization only the celebration of diversity and difference. Man does

Get Access