preview

The Monkey's Paw Compare And Contrast

Decent Essays
Open Document

The 2011 The Monkey’s Paw film version has a great, spooky atmosphere. But it could do with a bit of a change-up in the actors to make the atmosphere even more eerie; perhaps it would help to revamp the story by replacing some of the male actors with female ones. A few recent films such as the new Ghostbusters have recently replaced beloved male characters with female actors, to some very mixed reviews. Why, then, would I argue for replacing male with female in yet another film? It seems to be a recipe for popular disaster. However, the Ghostbusters change was done to well-known and familiar characters. Having even another male actor playing Bill Murray’s character would be strange to people. Making it quite so different threw the public completely. The Monkey’s Paw, on the other hand, is a somewhat obscure film and story. People would not already be accustomed to seeing a particular actor play a particular character. …show more content…

They aren’t played by a particular type of look of actor or actress. They could be played by almost anybody, as they are sort of “everyman/woman” character, just there as a conduit for the action—and there are quite a few actresses out there who would have done a better job of making the characters spooky than the actors in The Monkey’s Paw did. Not that they weren’t fine, but they weren’t perfect or inspired. For example, the man playing the main character, Sargeant-Major Morris, did a decent job of appearing travel-weary and dreadful and afraid. But Helena Bonham-Carter of Fight Club and Sweeney Todd fame would have had that extra edge of borderline insanity to raise the tension. She always has the edge of true inspiration that makes even humorous horror like Sweeney Todd chill you to the

Get Access