preview

The Music Of A Christmas Carol

Decent Essays

about it (Gaskell 18). James, who is another servant, tells Hester that she has mistaken “the wind soughing among the trees for music” (Gaskell 17). Hester must force Agnes, by way of rank, to reveal that it is believed that the dead “old lord”, plays the organ (Gaskell 18). Miss Furnivall is first connected with the music, when Hester claims that she thought it was her playing the organ (Gaskell 18). Being that Miss Furnivall is deaf, and is therefore an unlikely musician, this insinuates that Miss Furnivall is connected to this problem. However similar to “A Christmas Carol”, the music is suggested to be derived from ghostly means, because the organ is found to be broken inside, therefore unable to be played normally (Gaskell 18). This thought is later underlined when the child, Rosamond, goes missing, and ghosts threaten the household, further emphasizing that a problem exists (Gaskell 20,24).
Music is suggested many ways to cause her problems between Miss Furnivall and her sister, Miss Maude, rather than aid the sisters in a solution. Both sisters “fell in love with the same man, a foreign musician, whom their father had down from London to play music” (Gaskell 26). The sisters develop a rivalry over the foreigner (Gaskell 27). The foreigner is never given a name because it is suggested that he is not consequential as a person, but rather as a problem between the sisters. As he is of lower rank and not British, he is developed to play on Victorian fears, and social

Get Access