preview

The Nanking Massacre

Decent Essays

In this book, Iris Chang brings to light the atrocities that occurred during the Nanking massacre by focusing on the initial Japanese attacks on the city, the work of the international community to protect the Chinese, and the subsequent cover up of the massacre. Chang’s primary argument is that the events surrounding the Rape of Nanking have been downplayed by western and Japanese scholars, and need to be discussed. A key element of the book is to counter a revisionist approach to the events of Nanking which, in her estimation, pervade Japanese schools and have subsequently misled westerners into believing that the Japanese military was not as vicious as they were. Her work does indeed provide a gut-wrenching account of the event while sifting …show more content…

D.M. McKale contends that the Nazi Party’s work in the Far East had a negative impact on the German war effort and on its relationship with Japan. Historians have often focused on the Nazi Party in the United States, South America, and Southwest Africa, but rarely turn their attention to the Party’s activities in Asia thus important revelatory insights into the Nazi’s foreign policy have been neglected. McKale’s level-headed analysis links the German expat community during the Weimar Republic with the rise of the Nazi Party by highlighting the key figures and stubborn decisions that show the adverse effects of Volksgemeinschaft on aspects of diplomacy and Germany’s relationship with …show more content…

Sutton argues that the high reputation of the German advisors in China is overstated by historians, but the advisors did provide high quality service to the modernization of the Chinese military. The author attempts to dispel the myths surrounding the German advisory group, and demonstrate how the Nazi’s implementation of their military tactics altered the political landscape leading to the eventual break from the Nationalists, and alignment with the Japanese. While Sutton limits his article on the implications of the German’s training style, he does well to provide an alternative to the traditional conception of this group by reasonably making the point that not only has their reputation been somewhat exaggerated, but their impact may have prepared the Nationalists for the wrong style of war and not taken into account Chinese

Get Access