preview

The New Deal National Socialism Summary

Decent Essays

In John A. Garraty’s “The New Deal, National Socialism, and the Great Depression”, Garraty relates the Civilian Conservation Corps, or CCC, to nazi work camps, saying the two parallel each other as a tool to curb unemployment with a military education at their core1. However, the comparison of these programs is unfeasible as the CCC’s mission and methods of carrying out said mission were far less sinister and much more beneficial to its volunteers. The CCC prided itself on working for the common good, and the benefits it provided to those who partook. Relating this program to the harsh, deplorable camps established to build an army for hitler is obscene when looked at from a rational standpoint. The effect the CCC had on the US is important …show more content…

John Garraty claims that the CCC employed “Paramilitary and and patriotic functions not essential to its announced purpose”4, but in reality the CCC was far less militarized then many believed. While CCC camps were run by army officers, the camps were by no means militarized, “The CCC, however, did not require uniforms, drill young men in marching and weaponry, or require such protocols as salutes and deference to officers”5. The only reason the CCC can be considered military was that the department of war shared a responsibility in its formation6. However this was because the Army was the only organization capable of establishing and setting up such a large program. The transportation of thousands of volunteers, and establishment of hundreds of camps could only have been done through the army. But, with the absence of military training and protocol, one could hardly consider the CCC to be militarized in a fashion which was “not essential to its announced …show more content…

However this is once again untrue, as volunteers enjoyed many benefits in their time of service. The CCC provided workers with all the essentials they needed in their time at the camp, be it food, clothing, and shelter. This allowed workers to send the money they earned home to their families, around $25-$30 a month7, rather then having to spend it during their stay. This payment was a huge incentive to teenagers who wanted to help their families, as they could now help pay for their families expenses and take their own needs out of the picture. Camp life in the CCC also incentivized out of work teens, as personal accounts from volunteers portray a life of both work and play. Keith Hufford, a teen who enrolled in the CCC, describes some of the activities workers would take part in during their free time; “Before long, we were having inter-camp musical entertainments, boxing bouts, impromptu spelling bees, and quite often, interesting plays and sketches”8. This jubilant depiction serves as one of the many testimonies to the fun workers had during their time in the

Get Access