preview

The Old Man And The Sea Movie And Book Differences

Decent Essays
Open Document

The Ernest Hemingway's novella The Old Man and the Sea does a better job than Alex Petrov's painted on glass version of his story because the novel develops the extended struggle more clearly, relationships are developed more clearly, and the book gives the viewer an inside view of Santiago's mind. Although the movie presents beautiful images, its short length fails to deliver Santiago's struggle as vividly as the book. On page 85, the old man reflects that his left hand has cramped and failed him over the long fight with the marlin. His repeated complaints throughout the book makes the pain seem more real. Another example of his struggle that is clear in the book, but absent from the film, is his insistence on eating throughout the battle. On page 80, he chokes down warm, unsalted tuna because he wants to be strong. The movie eliminates these struggles and leaves the viewer thinking everything was easy. The book addresses these problems that the old man faces throughout the book. It shows that everything the old man did, came with a struggle and sign that he had to …show more content…

The movie does not demonstrate the old man taking down the picture. It does not even acknowledge that there is a picture of his wife. The book explains the boy, Manolin, and Santiago's relationship that they have more clearly. In the book, Manolin and Santiago are having breakfast while Santiago is looking at the newspaper. During breakfast they were discussing their favorite baseball player and managers. They talk about how they wanted with Di Maggio, their favorite baseball player. The boy then tells them the sold man that he is the greatest fisherman alive. The book shows that their relationship is so strong that it can't be broken. The movie doesn't show how much the old man loved Manolin like the book

Get Access