The One-Child policy is not being enforced like it would have been in ancient China.
During the Qin Dynasty Laws were carried in a stricter manner. For example Qin Shi Huangdi killed Daoist and Confucian scholars the burned their books because they would not change their ideology. However, in modern days such an act would not be tolerated by anyone and now instead of killing the people who broke the rule they are forced to get an abortion or sterilization. This shows that the Chinese government can control a person’s personal decision. Mrs.Dong a woman who was discovered to be pregnant with twins had “Without the agreement or signature of Mrs. Dong or her family” she was “injected Ethacridine Lactate”. Another example is “The brave pregnant woman who refuses to give in is usually detained and beaten…” (Chinese Twins Aborted) this shows that Legalism is still in China due to the fact that the government enforces laws harshly and unnecessarily brutally also having a huge influence on it’s people without consulting them.
…show more content…
The leniency towards those who follow the policy shows that the harshness that the Qin dynasty had is leaving modern China. Despite the fact that rule breakers are beaten they are not killed they are either arrested or beaten (Chinese Twins Aborted). Also some ethnic groups such as the Uighurs and Tibetans are excluded further proving that the government is not making everyone follow this rule only the general population. There are also exceptions for the general public for example families on the county side can have a second child if their first child is female (What is China’s One-Child Policy).These examples proves that legalist ideology is beginning to disintegrate however, is still stands firm in modern
Although the One-Child Policy in China had downfalls, the benefits overcome. In fact, many believe China’s One-Child Policy was not a good idea and had many flaws. I strongly believe China’s One-Child Policy was a sufficient theory in assisting environmental crises, strengthening feminine power, and revealing benefits of having singleton
One child policy gained a lot of critique and controversy during its implementation, especially for the issue of human rights abuse. The human rights abuse that happen during one child policy is referred to the women’s right. China says the one child policy that run more than 30 years has helped to reduce the population by more than 400 million people. However, critics are come from the international during the one child policy, China has been extensively criticized for forcing women to have abortions, sterilized, babies trafficking and give a punishment to those who disobey the rule as part of the policy. Moreover, there are wide reports about female baby infanticide by parents who want a son. Instead of bring a ‘pros’, one child policy of China is not only make the problems in the domestic area such as
The final reason that the one-child policy was a bad idea is because of the fact that China’s fertility rate was already decreasing and was one of the lowest rates compared to Brazil, South Korea, and Thailand in 1979 making the policy pointless and unnecessary. “The claim by the Chinese officials that the one child policy has helped avert over 400 million births simply cannot be substantiated by
There has been a long history of China’s one child policy, since it was first introduces in 1979 by a Chinese Leader Deng Xiaoping (Rosenberg n.p). The law was meant to be temporary and used to control the population; however it is still in use today (Rosenberg n.p). When the policy was first enforced, it only
“The government [then] reversed course and launched a campaign promoting birth control”(Soniak 1). Rules The one-child policy began in 1979, but not all of china was required to follow this law. “The policy applies to urban married couples who are part of the nations Han ethnic majority” (Soniak 1). For certain groups
The One-Child Policy has its pros and cons. It has benefited China as it reduced social problems, economic problems, environmental problems, and poverty. Of course, it has its downsides as well. This policy involves forced abortions and an increase in problems with family support. One must decide if the One-Child Policy is either necessary or a terrible idea. In my opinion, I honestly believe that the
In China there policy for birth control is a state policy and they must sustain it with no questions asked. The birth control system is a system that is assemble for punishment . The president of Women’s Rights without frontiers said “ Characterising this latest modifications abandoning the one-child policy misleading. Women are arrested if they refuse to have an abortion than it is is forced on them . The policy for China’s One Child Policy was made up on September 25, 1980.
Since 1980, China has made its people the subject of an intrusive and unfair, One Child Policy. This policy was the result of Chinese officials becoming worried of the countries jump in population from 1960 to 1980 causing a widespread lack of resources, so they decided to induct a law that would make force Chinese citizens to be limited to one child. Because of this controversial policy the question has been raised, did the one child policy positively or negatively effect China? The one child policy did negatively effect China and its people, because it resulted in gender discrimination, unjust punishments and was unnecessary due to the already declining fertility rate.
The one-child policy has caused many more issues than it has solved. The restrictions people must follow are causing a lot of the problems. One of the issues is that China will not relax the policy (Olesen 1). By limiting urban families to one child in a family, China is trying to conserve
China’s One-Child policy, implemented in 1980, “included both incentives and penalties to assure that couples produced only one child. Late marriages were encouraged, and free contraceptives, abortions, and sterilizations were provided to families that followed the policy. Penalties, including steep fines, were imposed on couples that had a second child.” (Wood 303). Though the policy has been relaxed in recent years, the negative results are hard to ignore.
China’s One-Child policy is needed to control the population of China’s rapid growth as well as maintaining a stable, healthy environment for all of China and the rest of the world to live in. Regardless of a heavy populated area’s whereabouts, population has a huge effect on the state of the earth so China’s One-Child policy is a good place to start. China wants to increase their population in fear they will drop their economic status at an astronomical rate, but in order to reduce a population and uphold their wealth something must change. That’s right: get rid of sexism. If the Chinese were to accept women in their society and be more willing to have a baby girl that would be a miracle. The one-child policy must stay, however, to ensure the population doesn’t get out of hand, but if girls weren’t aborted the population would make a steady comeback if that’s what the Chinese need to be economically sound. Finally, some Chinese people do not have a problem with having just one child. In fact, many couples are happy with one kid and wouldn’t want another; it’s just the fact that Chinese are being told how to live their lives and they do not accept those terms and conditions which is understandable. Overall, the one-child policy should stay in effect until the population of China has significantly
The ambition to obtain a son has always been deeply entrenched in a Chinese family. The one child policy has led to millions of female infants being aborted, neglected, or exterminated due to the cultural disgrace of having female children. The Chinese government had revised in 2014 that if couples, one of whom is an only child, will be allowed to have two children. Even though I do agree that this is a better change, an article in The New York Times recently reported that as many as half of the families affected by the new rules are balking at the idea of a second child saying that children just simply cost too much (Miks). I argue that females in China today should be able to have an equal status as males under their limited child policy
“Vigilantes abduct pregnant women on the streets and haul them off, sometimes handcuffed or troused, to abortion clinics (some) aborted babies cry when they are born,” said Steve Mosher. China’s policy was so strict to a point where they prevented a child’s birth just to keep the population number low. Statistics show that the Chinese government prevented over 400 million births. The one-child policy was implemented to curb a then surging population and limit the demands for water and other resources, as well as to alleviate social, economic, and environmental problems in China. One of the most significant effects of the policy has been on China’s sex ratio. China has a grossly unequal ratio of about 114 males to every 100 females. Due to the policy, many families were forced to only having one child. With that, baby boys were valued in China’s society than baby girls because boys carry on the ancestral name and are responsible for taking care of aged parents. Because of this many families would abandon their baby girl, sometimes leaving her on the streets, railways stations, and public buildings. The one-child policy left no more than sad memories for China’s nation. The law consisted of forced abortions and an unbalanced gender society. Although it was meant for the greater good of the people by decreasing the population to increase scarce resources, it caused many girls to be left abandoned by their own families.
This policy was beginning in 1979 that Chinese government required a married couple to have only one child, unless their fist kid is born with disabled. There had different implementations of the one-child policy in different area. Every urban couple, regardless of gender, required having only child in each family. Married couples would be fine for having more than one kid without a permit. Some people would be expelled for against the one-child policy if their jobs were related to the government as well as people who are working in public institution like school, hospital and media. In rural, if a couple’s first kid is a girl, they can have one more child. Because of the Chinese traditional values, one-child policy was created for population control, but this policy has resulted in many social problems, such as pension issue, gender discrimination and the mental
In fact, One-child policy is a great law which aim was to control China’s population and let China have more resources. It was introduced to Chinese people in 1979, 3 years after Mao’s death. Under the law, a couple was allowed to have only one child. However, as a lot of people were revolting the law, the