preview

The Peculiar Institution Analysis

Decent Essays

Mrs. Kostechka, Last night I conducted my homework reading assignment on The Peculiar Institution. On the surface this excerpt gives details on the conditions in which the antebellum south and north operated within the realm of slavery. It clearly covers what is to be believed the treatment, conditions, rights, and history on slavery in mainly the South. I read through this text three times before I sat down to complete the analysis section of the assignment. However, when critically looking at the text, I found somethings that I found to be not up to par with what should be taught in the class. Although the focus of the class was to examine history and "the way history is told", this text has clearly been written under the basis of the oppressors. This excerpt does not possess clear and accurate enough information to be used as a tool for educating students. It also clearly warrants pity on the minority of the text and is insensitive to the minority who reads it. …show more content…

However, the problem within the credibility of the text begins later on in that first paragraph where the author writes “The best accounts of what it was like to experience slavery were written by fugitive slaves...” followed by “Such men and women were not typical slaves... interviews with ex-slaves, conducted in the 1930’s, these accounts are flawed by the fact those who provided their recollections had only experienced slavery as children and their memories may well have been faulty.” This discredits the events of people who fought with their lives to get out of a system that was very well life changing with a simple ‘It's been so long now they don’t remember it

Get Access