preview

The Pros And Cons Of Organ Transplants

Decent Essays

Smoking has been a popular habit for hundreds of years. The effects of such lifestyle choices present the medical world with controversial issues. In many cases, treatment is offered to everyone, but should limitations be implemented in the medical fields with scarce resources? The issue arises in organ transplants, making the selection process for receivers ethically and economically challenging. One must consider that smoking is recognised as a mental illness, with addiction having been included in the diagnostic and statistical manual of mental disorders (DSM IV) which is recognised by professionals and by law (Lembke, 2014). Conversely, the medical professionals have both a legal and moral obligation to uphold ethical practices. It must also be considered the likelihood of a smoker re-damaging their lungs. Approximately 62% of organ transplants are performed on patients with smoking induced Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disorder (COPD), of which 11% return to the destructive lifestyle (Verleden, 2011). These ethically controversial issues invite the question: “Should people who submit to poor lifestyle …show more content…

The Australia and New Zealand cardiothoracic organ transplant registry recorded that 54% of the recipients on the lung transplant waiting list received organs. Only 38% of receivers were sufferers of diseases that were not self-inflicted (Bedford, 2014). Although addiction is a mental illness, the choice to begin smoking is the responsibility of the individual. With today’s understanding of the effects of cigarette smoke, it’s close to impossible for people to choose to smoke unbeknown of the effects of tobacco. Individuals who engage in poor lifestyle choices such as smoking may have prevented their illness, thus increasing the demand for organs (Donatelife, 2014), ultimately preventing patients who have no control over their illness receiving

Get Access