preview

The Purchased Paper By Skip Downing And Stephen Covey

Decent Essays
Open Document

In the case study of “The Purchased Paper,” a working college student named Edgar Allen has a dilemma: he believes his only option is to choose between going to college and having a job. At first glance, anyone might agree that his hands are tied, but by studying his behaviour using methods adapted by authors Skip Downing and Stephen Covey, it is easy to tell that Edgar not only has more options than he thinks, but is also playing a victim when it comes to personal responsibilities. According to Downing, author of On Course, when it comes to personal responsibility, there are two ends of the spectrum: creator and victim. A creator is someone who believes they have the sole responsibility for the outcome of their life, they understand that their actions have been ineffective, and strive to change them to “create the best results they can” (21-22). Though he uses different language to explain, Stephen Covey, author of The Seven Habits of …show more content…

Edgar Allen’s opening statement is fuelled entirely by emotion, making him what Covey calls a “hot reactor,” a big sign of playing victim. He is upset and therefore jumps to the worst possible conclusion—that his “college days are at an end”—rather than staying calm and evaluating his options (Covey). The major reason Edgar is a victim, however, is that he blames everyone else for his actions, not once taking a step back to think this may be his own fault, and that there are several choices he could make toward the best possible outcome. Instead, Edgar complains about having to work the entire weekend, and about not having enough time to write the paper assigned weeks ago; he blames his boss without even calling him to work out a solution, and his teacher for not extending the due date for him; he makes the excuse of being too tired to write every night he’d planned to, and yet still goes out Sunday night to celebrate (Downing

Get Access