preview

The Reflection Of Educational Dysfunctions

Satisfactory Essays

Educational Dysfunction The self creation of one’s identity is usually experienced during the period of adolescence, and the answer depends in large on who the world around them say they are. Our educational system role, is to gear students with the ability and determination for the job industry and diminish the possibility of poverty. Schools are there to inspire beliefs, character and roles and help achieve what's expected in our society. Although this may be true, today's educational system has ultimately left many students behind, there are children with outstanding potential, who at no time become aware of their natural potential. These three texts “Schools, Prisons, and Social Implications of Punishment,” by Pedro Noguera; “The Complexity of Identity,” by Beverly Tatum, and chapters 1 and 2 of Whistling Vivaldi, by Claude Steele give an insight in how school is not a place that gives all students, regardless of identity and categories of identification, a fair and equal chance at educational and future workplace success. In addition the same power structures that are accepted in society influence the way students, from kindergarten through college/university, are educated in the united states. In the text “Schools, Prisons, and Social Implications of Punishment,” by Pedro Noguera he gives various explanations on how our system is dysfunctional but for me only two stood out. When Noguera mentions, “When children are presumed to be wild, uncontrollable, and potentially dangerous, it is not surprising that antagonistic relations with the adults who are assigned to control them develop”.( 132-137)This quote stood out to me because in my 16 years of experience in school, I have witness professors judge a student before even interacting with them. On day one of my fourth grade year, I remember a classmate running around the classroom and yelling at the teacher. All because he was denied access to the bathroom, he then was considered the rotten apple of the class and was treated differently than the other students. He was placed in the corner half of the time and sent to the principal’s office for various reasons. The student was an outcast by the teacher and classmates even by me. The second quote

Get Access