In David Herbert Lawrence’s short story, The Rocking Horse Winner, a boy sets out on a quest to look for luck. His luck inevitably allows him to win money betting on horses. The money he has earned is used in an effort to gain his mother’s love. Although, he was left with was his mother’s stone heart. Lawrence displays that money doesn’t buy happiness.
The question at issue in this short story is, does the protagonist, Paul, receive a sense of love, satisfaction, and security with his single pursuit of money?
Some readers find that Paul does receive a sense of love, satisfaction, and security from his sole pursuit of money. Religious literary critic, Charles Koban, believes that she loves Paul more than she did her husband. If Hester truly
…show more content…
Paul states,“Then what is luck mother? Its what causes you to have money. Thats why its better to be born lucky than rich. If you're rich, you may lose your money. But if you're lucky, you will always get more money.”(Lawrence 593). It is Paul’s understanding that it is luck that will make him rich. After keeping his gambling a secret, he finally admits to his mother that he’s been betting at the derby and that he is lucky. His hard work was all for nothing. After he admits his winnings, she still doesn’t acknowledge the hard work he put in to satisfy her. When a person tries hard to accomplish something and is shut down it leaves them devastated. It is Paul’s quest and drive for his mother’s love that allows him to persist in the pursuit of money. “‘I never told you, mother, that if I can ride my horse, and get there, then I'm absolutely sure —oh, absolutely! Mother, did I ever tell you? I am lucky!’ ‘No, you never did,’ said his mother”(Lawrence 602). The eighty-thousand pounds he received from his last betting was the price of Paul’s death. Paul rocking back and forth furiously and anxiously symbolizes that he was only a laborer for Hester. His labor working and anxiety was the cause of his
The short story that has the best quality off literary fiction would be, The Rocking-Horse Winner by D H Lawrence, a story about a young boy trying to win his mother’s love by seeking the luck she thinks she does not have also, wanting to give her the luxurious lifestyle she dreams of by betting on horse races he begins to make money to hopefully make everything better. This short story represents setting, plot, theme, symbol and character very well. Without these main points of emphasis being made a short story would have no structure so that’s what I feel is most important.
In “The Rocking-Horse Winner,” by D. H. Lawrence, and “The Lottery,” by Shirley Jackson, the two authors illustrate symbols and themes throughout their stories in which one common idea is present: perhaps winning is not always positive.
One of the emotional essentials of life is to be loved, and there are quite a few cases where material things can hinder receiving this much-needed love, the greatest culprit of all being money. D. H. Lawrence’s short story “The Rocking Horse Winner” tells of a boy, Paul, who desires love and affection from his mother, Hester, but she is so wrapped up in her concerns with money that she does not display any of this needed affection toward her son or any of her children. She has grown unloving and bitter due to her husband’s inability to meet her expectations, and she tells Paul his father is unlucky. Full of curiosity, Paul asks his mother what luck is, and she tells him, “‘It’s what causes you to have money. If you’re lucky you have money. That’s why it’s better to be born lucky than rich. If you’re rich, you may lose your money. But if you’re lucky, you will always get more money” (Lawrence, 2). Paul is quite intuitive and interprets that the only way he can finally obtain love from his mother is if he is lucky, much unlike his father. He proudly shares with his mother that he is lucky, but when she does not take his word seriously, he falls into a blinded rage as he madly rides his rocking horse, hoping it will take him to where the luck is, “‘Now take me to where there is luck!’” (3). By riding his rocking-horse, he knows which horse will win the derby. The association of love with money brings about the idea of a love for money, or greed, which is one of the seven
In “The Rocking Horse Winner” by D. H. Lawrence, an immense amount of attention is poured towards the focus of money. Today, who someone is depends drastically upon the amount of money they have. Sadly, money determines who you are before you even realize it. The same idea is developed into this story. An essay says, “While his father is a hard worker, he does not bring in enough money to satisfy the expensive tastes of the latter’s wife. Because of this, Paul’s mother resents her husband and makes it clear that she wants more monetary benefits out of life” (Pierce). Although she may not realize it, Paul’s mother is beginning to demand so much of her husband that it not only wears out her husband, but continually rubs off onto Paul. Paul becomes so bothered by the thought that his family has little to none money, and his only desire is to change that feeling for his family. He begins to realize that he wants nothing but money for his family so they can experience life in such a way that they are able to enjoy what they have and obtain more. As Paul is growing up amid such an issue, he begins to realize that no matter what he is doing, he is constantly being reminded that his family is destitute. “He was looking so extraordinarily foolish for no other reason but that he heard the secret whisper all over the house: “There must be more money” (Page 1248). Given the circumstances, everything that Paul did reminded him subtly about the family issue. Because of
Throughout the modern era, society’s views on money’s effect on a person’s emotions have drastically changed. Many people believed that the more money a person has, the more satisfied he or she will be. However, due to recent conclusions made by writers and case studies, money has proven to not be responsible for a person’s contentment. In F. Scott Fitzgerald’s novel, The Great Gatsby, Daisy and Gatsby’s wealth ultimately shows the reader that money does not equal happiness.
In my opinion, I do not feel that Paul would have been any happier if he was born rich. Throughout the story, Paul desires to be rich; however, he had too many other issues other than just being rich. Paul was not happy with himself, his family, his sexuality and the loss of his mother.
When a person is lucky, it does not have to mean that they are fortunate with money. Luck is the chance for things to go the way you want them to go with out having any control over the situation. In The Rocking Horse Winner, Hester, the mother seems to believe that luck is strictly having money, and when there is no money, there is no luck. Hester's idea of luck meaning money brings forth the two ideas of greed and death throughout the story.
The role of money is merely to buy attention. Hester wants to use it to buy acceptance in the higher classes, and Paul wants to use it to buy his mother’s affection. The attention the characters seek is only superficial, however. The attention is based on outward signs of prosperity. Hester’s family is considered the best on the block because everything they own looks rich and expensive, but they are in great debt. Hester’s compassion for Paul is also based on this money- presents are the only things that show her love. This never stops Hester from pushing for more luxuries in an attempt to win this false admiration. Of course, in the end, Hester’s vanity will cost them
Paul desire his mother’s love more than anything. However he believes he needs to prove he is lucky. He struggles to prove that he is to make his mother happy. Paul wants his mother to love him more than anything. For Paul’s mother money equals luck, and this will gain her love. “There must be more money”(19). He hears these voices throughout the house. They hear these voices when hey are receiving items of joy, especially around Christmas time. The other children can hear the voices and so can the rocking horse Paul received. Even though they can hear the voices they do not say anything. This is due to the fact that every one is used to it so it would be like saying “we are breathing”(20). This led Paul to realizes that there family is in debt and he believes that in order for them to get out of this debt, he has to take action. This shows that he is willing to take the problem into his own hands because he believes that no one else can do anything about
“The Rocking Horse Winner” is a short story written by D.H Lawrence that follows the short and tragic life of a boy named Paul, who assumes he has amazing luck after realizing he can predict racehorse winners by furiously riding his rocking horse until he reaches a trance-like state. Unfortunately, as his family takes advantage of his gift and starts gaining more money, Paul’s luck begins to kill him. Literally. Throughout the story, there are several themes evident, such as wealth, life, conscious, existence; luck, family, and greed. The conflicts displayed are man vs man, man vs self, and man vs. society. The rocking horse has become an obsession for paul and the potential benefits it would have on his family, ultimately not knowing the actual harm it will cause.
Lawrence. His mother was someone who would always complain and talk about the fact that there was no money in the family. Bassett was also someone who had a very large influence on Paul and his gambling habits. Finally, Uncle Oscar was also someone who had a large influence on Paul and even helped him come to and make the final decisions in his life that would ultimately be the end. Money was something that really had a large influence on Paul and how he made his decisions. Because these people and their influence on money, Paul eventually met his end because of his desires to please these
In Rocking Horse Winner Lawrence brings up some questions about economics. In the story the little boys mother tells her son that they aren’t lucky because they don’t have any money. Even though the family has money they don't have enough for how they are choosing to live. To their family money matters. “Money is essential for living, but insufficient for striving”(Tatzel). This quote states that money indeed is important to survive but you don't need a lot, just enough to get you by. In the story the mom wants more. She is never happy with how much she has, because she doesn't have enough. In the story children hear the house speaking to them saying “there must be more money”(pg.1248). This is proving that there are economic questions a rising. The
In summary, the desire for money and social status ends up in taking the protagonist's life. The author, D.H. Lawrence reveals the theme exceedingly well through the use of relations between the engraved characters and the symbolic inferences. Paul in the end receives the attention and love which he longs for, but unfortunately his mother realizes this too late. The author in the end succeeds in revealing the theme which makes this short story more
Throughout history, many people struggle with greed. Greed is defined as a selfish desire for something. Throughout the story each character faces there own form of greed, whether they know it or not each action impacts each other and leads to the death of the mother’s son. In the short story “The Rocking-Horse Winner”, the author D.H lawrence uses a rocking horse, wealth, and lack of family intimacy to illustrate to the reader the disastrous problems with greed.
Lawrence also uses a few well placed images to show the reader the difference between working for one's money and then investing it wisely, and squandering money that one does not know the value of. The first set of images include Paul furiously rocking away at his riding the wooden horse, to find "where there is luck." Paul understood that if he was to succeed, he would have to work, despite what people said about his work. This knowledge also gave him a sense of the value of any money he collected. Another of the first group of images include Paul's method of investment of his gains. Because of the effort he had to expend, he was not about to spend his money unwisely. Instead, he invested it in sure deals, always being cautious when he was "not quite sure." He even kept a reserve in case of the unthinkable. The second set of images include Hester, who receives her money without having to work for it, getting no sense of it's worth. Upon gaining the five thousand Paul leaves aside for her, she immediately spends it on superfluous things, causing the voices in the walls to "simply trill and scream in a sort of ecstasy."