I was a little surprised by how much more difficult the creative project was than the essay. But only a little, creativity is tough! From evaluating the critical theory to coming up with a method to re-express and respond to the theory, the assignment demanded thoughtfulness. I chose to respond to George Arms’ essay, “Contrasting Forces in the Novel.” In his essay, he points out the multitude of the conflicts in Enda’s life and character. He discusses Edna’s wildly shifting feelings about her children, how she loves them deeply, only to feel detached and passive about them a moment later. Arms also looks at her sexuality, and sleepiness in the face of an “awakening.”
I see Edna’s suicide as another paradox. Throughout the novel, Edna discovers what she truly wants: to be her own person in the world, and to love and be loved without being owned. But the moment Edna knows what she wants from life, she decides that the only way to have some of it, to be her own person, is to no longer be alive. Even though Edna becomes wildly aware of the nuances of life, she sees her own existence as a dichotomy: Either she lives with
…show more content…
Edna’s discoveries throughout the novel are things she wants from life, not things she wants in death. She cannot love when she’s dead. Though looking for a partner was no easy task, she was making forward progress when she was alive. Despite becoming aware of life’s multidimensionality, she maintains views of romance that are flat. She believes she cannot live alone like Mademoiselle Reisz, but views this as the only alternative to a picturesque romance. Though none of the other characters can own her while she is dead, she cannot really own herself while she’s dead either. The only thing she can control is her death, but that ignores the many things she can still control in her life that are far better alternatives for Edna than
By having these experiences with Robert she is trying to go beyond herself. A quote that indicates her start for self actualization is, "Mrs. Pontellier was beginning to realize her position in the universe as a human being, and to recognize her relations as an individual to the world within and about her... How many souls perish in its tumult!" (17). Here the narrator foreshadows the turmoil that will result from Edna’s search of self actualization. It seems to suggest that from the moment her awakening begins, Edna is marked for death. Aside from her automatic damnation it is also impossible for Edna to reach her self actualization because of her conflicting selves or "two Edna's". “Even as a child she had lived her own small life all within herself. At a very early period she had apprehended instinctively the dual life—that outward existence which conforms, the inward life which questions" (18). This quote supports that there are "Two Ednas", an Inner and Outer. The Outer Edna conforms to societal expectations while the Inner Edna questions her
Edna fails to control her impulses of her sexual desires and willingly breaks social conformity of her era. She undoubtedly leaves her family to pursue a life without her children and husband. “The acme of bliss, which would have been marriage with the tragedian, was not for her in this world. As the devoted wife of a man who worshipped her, she felt she would take her place with a certain dignity in the world of reality, closing the portals forever behind her upon the realm of romance and dreams” (Chopin 21). Edna felt destined to live the fantasy life, and with that she believed starting over in another relationship would best benefit her. Morally, this wasn’t acceptable to society around her and she would be seen as a bad mother and wife, yet this did not seem to phase her. Further on Edna takes a moment to reflect if what she is doing is what she believes is following her passions. “But as she sat there amid her guests, she felt the old ennui overtake her; the hopelessness which so often assailed her, which came upon her like an obsession, like something extraneous, independent of volition. … There came over her the acute longing which always summoned into her spiritual vision the presence of the beloved one”(Chopin 159). After Edna realizes that following her passions may have led her to the wrong place, she finds herself still in a position she can be happy with, which is with the “beloved one”. Edna has
Edna’s awakening was the beginning to her suicide. As Edna realized her capacity to be honest with herself, the old Edna began to die. Edna slowly started to realize she did not want to be like other women, whom “idolized their children, worshiped their
She is moved by music. During that summer Edna sketches to find an artistic side to herself. She needs an outlet to express who she is. Edna feels that art is important and adds meaning to her life. After the summer is over and they are back to the city and Edna is a changed woman. She makes many steps towards independence. She stops holding "Tuesday socials", she sends her children to live in the country with their grandparents, she refuses to travel abroad with her husband, she moves out of the Lebrun house on Esplanade Street, and to earn money, she starts selling her sketches and betting the horses. She also starts a relationship with another man Alcee Arobin. He meant nothing to her emotionally but she used him for sexual pleasure. Edna evolved above her peers she did not believe that sexuality and motherhood had to be linked. The last step of her "awakening" is the realization that she can not fulfill her life in a society that will not allow her to be a person and a mother. Edna commits suicide in the ocean at Grand Isle.
By giving her children a sense of independance early which may enable them for success later on. While other children of the times may have a pseudo unhealthy reliance on a mother, much like Robert's brother Victor who still lives at home. Another more risky thing she did was make a statement that most women even now wouldn't agree with. Edna states: “I would give up the unessential; I would give up my money, I would give my life for my children; but I wouldn't give myself.”(Chopin 47) This statement holds quite a lot of weight in the way we can view edna. Some may call her selfish for a lack of an undying love for her children. But I view it as brutal honesty. The fact that edna is coming to this conclusion and fighting the ever pushing stream of society really shows how she is trying to fight. Giving up one's self is a very dangerous thing to do. For once you give too much you can lose who you are. But too little and people can lose sight of what you can be/who you are. As a mother edna realizes this and decides to make herself known in a different way than as a mother-woman.
The final reason for Edna’s escape from her troublesome life is the failure of her relationship with Robert. Edna was able to find some form of escape through her desire and hope of being with Robert, but when those plans fell through Edna feels as if she has nothing to look forward to, nothing to live for in life. Robert realizes that he and Edna will never be able to have a true
The Awakening was a very exciting and motivating story. It contains some of the key motivational themes that launched the women’s movement. It was incredible to see how women were not only oppressed, but how they had become so accustomed to it, that they were nearly oblivious to the oppression. The one woman, Edna Pontellier, who dared to have her own feelings was looked upon as being mentally ill. The pressure was so great, that in the end, the only way that she felt she could be truly free was to take her own life. In this paper I am going to concentrate on the characters central in Edna’s life and her relationships with them.
The thoughts and feelings circulating through Edna Pontellier help the reader better understand her character and how she changes throughout the book. For Example, Kate Chopin writes, “The years that are gone seem like dreams—if one might go on sleeping and dreaming—but to wake up and find—oh! well! Perhaps it is better to wake up after all, even to suffer, rather than to remain a dupe to illusions all one’s life.” CHAPTER 38. Saying that it is better to suffer rather than to go through life unconsciously is a very important theme in this novel because that is what Edna Pontellier's awakening is all about. Kate Chopin uses this quote because Edna would rather suffer with the wisdom she has gained, rather than going through life tending to her husband's and children's every need. Edna is going against her womanly duties and is again becoming independent. This is what
James Justus, who is also a critic of American literature, questions what Edna awakens to and if in fact her awakening is at
Still the societal obligations she once held haunt Edna as those around her still admonish her decision to leave her family behind. Edna explains her decision to leave to Doctor Mandalet saying, “The years that are gone seem like dreams—if one might go on sleeping and dreaming—but to wake up and find—oh! well! Perhaps it is better to wake up after all, even to suffer, rather than to remain a dupe to illusions all one’s life ” (624) Edna’s explanation of her awakening shows her logical conclusion to end her life because she believes that a temporary awakened life worth more than a long life lived mindlessly. Edna accepts herself selfishness and does not look to retreat back to her former life but to continue to live her life in a radical manner, even if that means a radical and early ending to her life.
From even the first few chapters of the novel it is evident that Edna is becoming aware of her concealed wants and desires as she begins to distance herself from the society that she considers herself to be an outsider in. While walking in town Edna
The reader thinks Edna might just be frustrated with her husband. As the novel shifts to New Orleans, it is clear that she has changed. Edna starts to feel motivated to take action. Finally the setting comes back to Grand Isle, and it is the climax of Edna’s awakening. It is also where she drowns herself. Nobody know for sure whether it was intentional or not since Chopin said, “Even as a child she had lived her own small life all within herself. At a very early period she had apprehended instinctively the dual life—that outward existence which conforms, the inward life which questions”(Chopin 58).
Edna reassesses her spirit more and more as the novel proceeds, with her finally reaching the maxim when committing suicide. At the beginning of the novel she is completely
The Awakening by Kate Chopin ends with the death of the main character, Edna Pontellier. Stripping off her clothes, she swims out to sea until her arms can no longer support her, and she drowns. It was not necessarily a suicide, neither was it necessarily the best option for escaping her problems.
The remaining question for the reader is: Does Edna's suicide show that she succeeded or failed in her struggle for independence?