The Roles of Women and the Differences in Lifestyles in A Scandal in Bohemia and The Speckled Band

1626 Words 7 Pages
The Roles of Women and the Differences in Lifestyles in A Scandal in Bohemia and The Speckled Band


‘A Scandal in Bohemia’ and ‘The Speckled Band’ are two short detective
stories written by Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. They are set in England in
the mid 19th century. Both of the stories are narrated by Dr Watson,
who is one of the main characters. The other main character is
Sherlock Holmes and he is an amateur detective. Both stories have a
main female character and I am going to compare these female
characters by looking at their personalities and the circumstances in
which they live in. In ‘A Scandal in Bohemia’, Irene Alder is the
female character and she is a retired Opera singer. Helen Stoner, a
…show more content…
Although she is ‘retired from the operatic
stage’, she was the ‘Prima donna Imperial Opera of Warsaw’.

Irene Alder is a very wealthy woman who has obviously earned a lot
from being an opera singer. She has a big house that has a ‘large
sitting room on the right side, well furnished with long windows
almost to the floor’. Irene is kind and tender hearted towards
Sherlock Holmes and takes him into this house when he is supposedly
injured. Dr Watson describes ‘the grace and kindliness with which she
waited upon the injured man’.

Irene Adler is not just very talented, she is also clever. Twice she
has outsmarted the King of Bohemia – ‘twice she has been waylaid.
There was no result’. She also manages to get the better of Sherlock
Holmes and this is probably the only time that a lady has managed to
do that. As well as being clever, she is also cunning. The King
himself tells Sherlock Holmes that there ‘are no lengths to which she
would no go – none’. We know that she is even prepared to blackmail,
but only after falling in love with Godfrey Norton, she keeps the
photograph, but ‘only to safeguard’ herself. She is a very romantic
person. She says that she ‘loves and is loved’. This shows that it is
more important to her than money or social standing.

Helen Stoner is quite different from Irene Adler. She is a very timid
woman but this may be because she is very…