preview

The Silmarillion Chapter Summary

Decent Essays

Thus Douglas Charles Kane sets forth the inspiration for his meticulous review of the origin of the text Christopher Tolkien presented in 1977 as The Silmarillion. I confess that I myself belonged to the second group, until the publication of The History of Middle-earth volumes revealed the extent of the evolution of the Legendarium. Christopher has presented that evolution roughly in a chronological format, with The Book of Lost Tales containing Tolkien’s earliest writings and The War of the Jewels the latest concerning the tales of The Silmarillion. Anyone interested in following the development of a single tale, therefore, must work through portions of multiple volumes. Kane, who calls The Silmarillion “arguably his most important work” (23), set out to show how Christopher, with the assistant of Guy Gavriel Kay, put together what has become the settled text of The Silmarillion. Kane proceeds through The Silmarillion chapter by chapter, showing the source within The History of Middle-earth for each paragraph. [Additionally, he referred rarely to “Unfinished Tales, The Children of Húrin, and, in at least one instance, Tolkien’s letters” (25).] Each chapter of Kane’s book contains a table detailing his findings. For example, for Chapter 13 “Of the Return of the Noldor,” paragraph 1 was taken from the ‘later Quenya’ paragraph 88, …show more content…

Not only do we lose a fuller understanding of two female characters, we lose insight into Tolkien’s thoughts about Elven ‘death.’ Kane posits that Christopher was concerned about the book’s length, but nevertheless considers this choice in particular to be a great loss to The

Get Access