preview

The State Of Librariancy : Article Analysis

Better Essays

Buschman discusses the state of librarianship after the 2016 presidential election. The fact that “facts” no long alter views causes a serious problem not just for the media, but for library professionals as well. Even fact checking implies there is a balance between both sides of an issue, when in fact one side is so wrong it is misleading even to discuss it seriously. The amount of untruth that exists undermines the core values. He tells of the issue of the fiasco of the first press release from the ALA after the election led to another press release regretting the first press release and then documents were removed from the web and the first release retracted with a statement that recommitted to advancing the ALA’s core values. …show more content…

She provides background her review, using Birdsall’s theory of progressive librarianship as the basis for her approach, especially the restructuring the flow of information so it moves horizontally through people instead of coming from the top down.

The literature review is extensive, but focused primarily on what the author finds to be “unique perspectives”. The library integrating Web 2.0 features encourages more patron participation, so instead of just reading information, users can talk to each other and even create their own content. This is cited as an example of how information can be generated from the bottom up.

Internet filtering that is required by the Children’s Internet Protection Act (CIPA), can be ineffective and block appropriate content, thus decreasing intellectual freedom. Also, it can damage the equalizing force of libraries by causing more harm to those libraries with already limited resources. Surveillance and privacy are also discussed. Librarians must preserve the standards of privacy for their patrons, especially in light of the collection of data by Google and Facebook.

In conclusion, Childs argues that public librarians must defend intellectual freedom by “embracing their political agency and actively combating censorship and surveillance”. This article is a good literature review for recent articles on public libraries and intellectual freedom challenges.

Dreyfuss, S., & Ryan, M. (2016, January).

Get Access