preview

The Sweet Hereafter and "The Pied Piper of Hamelin" Essay

Decent Essays

"The Sweet Hereafter and the Pied Piper"

A tragic event can occur in no longer than a moment and produce a domino effect that can change everything in your life. The book "The Sweet Hereafter" by Russell Banks contains such an event. This book has a modernized undertone of the folk tale "The Pied Piper of Hamelin" by Robert Browning. This tale is carried throughout the books entirety. Both of these stories show connections in many ways and almost parallel one another in their basic plot of showing the painful effects disaster can have on a small town. While the people of Hamlin had the Piper to directly blame for their miseries, the people of Sam Dent did not.

Both stories are based on the loss of the children in a small …show more content…

At the end of the book "The Sweet Hereafter" one of the only children left to survive the accident is a young girl named Nicole Burnell. Though she escapes narrowly with her life she is crippled and confined to a wheelchair thereafter. Her dreams of becoming a beauty queen or a rock star are dashed. Similarly in the tale of "The Pied Piper" the town is left with only one child who is crippled and thus was unable to keep up with the rest of the children as they followed the Piper into the cave dancing in an enchanted trance.

In both stories we later learn that these characters whom are left behind almost wish they had not been spared. The crippled boy from "The Pied Piper" is in fact said to be sad at not being able to share "all the pleasant sights" that he believes his playmates are seeing in a heaven-like land described to them by the Piper himself. In the time immediately following the accident Nicole Burnell could be described as having these similar feelings. In reality both of these characters disabilities ended up saving them. In the case of the crippled boy his lameness kept him from being taken away forever by the Piper, like all the other children. In the case of Nicole Burnell her gained disability gave her control and power over the incestuous situation she was in with her own father, it saved her from further sexual abuse.

In the tale of the Pied Piper

Get Access