preview

The Truant And Earle Birney's 'Vancouver Lights'

Decent Essays

E.J. Pratt’s “The Truant” and Earle Birney’s “Vancouver Lights” have much in common: both poems express humanist ideologies, both use historical context and large metaphors, and both prize most highly human reason and responsibility. Each poem deals with paradoxes in its assessment of human reason. However, while each poem similarly reflects on the fate of humanity, Pratt uses his religious views to offer a decisive ending—even though the rest of his poem deals in more ambiguous terms—while Birney maintains an ironic tone throughout. Pratt seems to want to confirm the power of human reason alone as sufficient but asserts a religious answer at the end of "The Truant," weakening the humanist of his poem in comparison to Birney’s paradoxical and …show more content…

“Vancouver Lights” presents the nature of humans as something infinitely complex and impossible to clearly define. Pratt chooses to end with the Truant defying the Panjandrum and stating that “[we] have taught our souls to rally”, that humanity will join together and use human reason to overcome the problems of a deterministic universe, and in the historical context that the war will be won by the Allies (Pratt 182). However, Pratt takes his humanist view and adds in Christian belief, “by the Rood” to come up with one final solution (Pratt 191). By doing so Pratt reduces the complexity of humanity and loses that ambiguous tone of “The Truant”. Ironically, in coming to a single answer, Pratt creates a paradox with the rest of his poem and his humanist view; however, this new paradox does not change the singular conclusion of the poem. The reasons for Pratt addition of religion are unknown; perhaps he did not believe in the strength of his humanist view or he believed that religion could provide a sufficient answer. The issue of Pratt’s inclusion of religion does not have a simple answer and its inclusion in Pratt work does raise questions. Birney, comparatively, cannot offer an answer and stays within the realms of human complexity with the ironic ending of “there was light” (Birney 40). The paste tense adds to the ironic quality as the reader cannot be sure if Birney is celebrating the existence of light from humanity or if there is a resignation due to the negative power of the light. The line is also directed to a “Plutonian” to let them know of what humanity has done with their light but never lets the reader know if this is a positive or negative message (Birney 39.) Birney does prize human reason,

Get Access