preview

The Woman In Black Comparative Essay

Decent Essays
Open Document

The movie, The Woman in Black, directed by James Watkins and the novel, The Woman in Black, written by Susan Hill both portray the elements of gothic literature; although the movie uses gothic literature better than Hill’s novel. There are many elements of gothic literature like castles, the supernatural, wild nature, sublime, metonymy, emotional intensity, confinement, the past, woman in distress, etc...
The movie, The Woman in Black, by Susan Hill portrays a more happy ending. In the ending of the movie Arthur and his son, Joseph, end up being with his mother and Arthur’s ex-wife. The very last scene of the movie (scene 16) the woman in black, Jennet Humfrye, show her face. In this scene it shows women in distress which is an element of gothic literature. This moment also intensifies the end of the story with her horrifying body. Also in scene 16 Watkins decided to put all the kids that …show more content…

In the novel Arthur, Esme, and Joseph are at a large park about 10 miles out from London. All of them have been reunited in a very happy place. The reader at this point is now feeling very content about the situation because Arthur has finally escaped from the horror of the women in black. The woman in black is a supernatural being and helps present this element. In this part of the book the woman in black is hiding behind a tree hoping that Arthur will see her. Jennet wants everyone to pay for what they had done to her son. She is a dark being, that normally comes out when there is fog or its night time. This makes the story more horrifying and suspenseful. It also represents sublime which has a lot to do with the weather and nature. Every time someone sees the Jennet Humfrye a child has to die because she lost her son. Arthur says (1983) , “Oh, pray God it may not - that the chain is broken - that her power is at an end - that she has gone - and I was the last to ever see her” (pg.

Get Access