preview

Themes In John Gardner's 'Beowulf'

Decent Essays

Themes are a pivotal element of writing. They set the basis for stories, give purpose to a novel, and provide a deeper meaning to a message. Whilst many themes will be present in a novel, one usually will shine the brightest, and will define the piece. Author John Gardner’s spin on the epic poem Beowulf, Grendel, is a prime example of a piece with a major, establishing theme. This prevailing theme throughout the novel is the idea of how monsters and men are both different and similar. This key concept and theme found throughout Grendel highlights the differences between monsters and men, the similarities, and what defines the divide between the brutes and the intellectuals. It also delves in the creation of distinct, monster-human roles …show more content…

Grendel originally was a creature of survival; he killed to stay alive, and when he saw what humans do to each other in war, he was appalled, saying “I was sickened, if only at the waste of it: all they killed cows, horses, men-they left to rot or burn.” (Gardner 36). This wastefulness and utter disregard for life is what begins to spark his critical opinion on humans. Grendel also is slowly moved to see humans as evil and ruthless by all of the smaller pieces of evidence of a ruthlessness that begin to add up. These initial events and spectacles give him an initial interest and strong opinion for humans that will eventually pushed Grendel into hatred for humans. However, despite his rage, Grendel also becomes fascinated, unable to avert his attention from human behavior. As Grendel begins to realize this evilness of humans, he starts to change his attitude, increasing his aggression to match …show more content…

This is the sort of wasteful behavior that Grendel originally found atrocious and disgraceful in man. However, Grendel sees this violence through a different lens, yet when compared to the warfare and violence of Danes it appears nearly identical. He also begins to justify his violence later saying “I made him what he is. Have I not the right to test my own creation?” (Gardner 123). This justification is not exclusive to Grendel by any means though. Humans too are prone to having scapegoats and explanations for attacks. Enter Red Horse, a man that believes in what he calls “Legitimate violence”, and he states that “Revolution… is not the substitution of immoral for moral, or of illegitimate for legitimate violence; it is simply pitting power against power…” (Gardner 119). This statement rings true in the tale. Grendel’s use of violence is just as justified as the men that fought and left all of the cattle to rot in chapter 3. These many similarities tie Grendel and the Danes together. In Grendel’s mind they need each other. He thinks that Hrothgar and himself are now one, and Grendel causes Hrothgar to have a dream about how reliant the two are on each other. The dream details a twisted tree of two trunks that have grown together

Get Access