preview

Thomas Mappes

Good Essays
Open Document

Analyses of Thomas Mappes Essay
In Thomas Mappes essay, “Sexual Morality and the Concept of Using Another Person,” the idea of voluntary informed consent in sexual activity is evaluated through several scenarios which display the principle of humanity. Despite an in-depth analysis of informed consent and its relationship to sexual mortality, Mappes, fails to address the issue of sexual harassment.
The idea of voluntary informed consent is outlined in Mappes essay. This idea is formed around two main principles: information and autonomy. An individual has voluntary informed consent if all the information is provided for them, in order to allow them to make an informed decision. Immoral use of voluntary informed consent occurs through deception and coercion. Deception could include lying to another individual, or withholding …show more content…

How could Mappes discuss coercion without including sexual harassment? In Mappes essay, there are two types of coercion: offers and threats. In Mappes mind, threats have “the effect of rendering a person worse off upon noncompliance…” Mappes, on the other hand, believes offers are “ordinarily welcome to a person” as the person is no worse off than before if they do not accept. However, I think sexual harassment is present in both threats and offers. Sexual harassment is defined by the Oxford Dictionaries as the “harassment in a workplace, or other professional or social situation, involving the making of unwanted sexual advances or obscene remarks.” Mappes discounts this variable as he essentially presents an offer as a positive. An offer is still an inappropriate and immoral act in my opinion. In this case of an offer, an individual is still being harassed for sexual favors. Overall, I do think Mappes discernment for sexual harassment weakens his overall argument; however one can still acknowledge the differences between a coercion threat and

Get Access