preview

Time Travel Heracliten

Decent Essays

It is not uncommon to see instances of time travel in science fiction films or TV shows. However, the popularity of this theme in fictional stories does not construe a general acceptance in the scientific community that it is feasible. In “The Case of Time Travel,” Phil Dowe seeks to provide a rebuttal to William Grey’s “Troubles With Time Travel,” an article written to debunk the possibility of time travel. Dowe strives to repudiate what he calls issues against time travel propounded by Grey. In particular, in “Troubles With Time Travel,” Grey has raised four issues, namely no destinations, double occupation, time paradox, and possibility restriction; nevertheless, according to Dowe, what Grey terms as observable objections to time travel hypothesis can be explained or challenged by other ideas.
The Grey-Dowe Debate
Firstly, the no destinations objection, based on the Heracliten understanding of time, opines that there is no future to travel to …show more content…

Grey’s claim that what one can do, whether in the past or future, is limited to a fixed set of facts is considered a fallacy because theoretically time travel imposes no unusual restrictions (Dowe 448). The idea of possibility of restrictions is not well explained, but Dowe discredits an equally baffling analogy that people are never able to do those things they would ordinarily do.
All in all, the core arguments by William Grey, no destinations, double occupation, time paradox, and possibility restriction, which seek to prove that time travel is impossible, have rebuttals. However, in a bid to drum up support for his point of view, Dowe has offered his rejoinder without in-depth explanations as to why Grey’s ideas are preposterous. The outcome is the article that leaves a lot in abeyance, further muddling the discourse on time

Get Access