preview

Timmermans

Decent Essays

Timmermans: Evidence based medicine and the reconfiguration of medical knowledge.

EBM or evidence based medicine is a form of protocols used to standardize diagnoses and treatment plans. In this journal we learn details about the four medical professionalization theories and we also learn what Timmermans believes to be the downfalls of those theories. The effects of EBM on the medical profession are stated as being the fact that medicine shifts from pathophysiology to epidemiology with guidelines, these guidelines seem to interfere with the autonomy of the practitioner. There are three questions that the journal is interested in evaluating. The first question has to do with whether the epistemological characteristics of medicine are more …show more content…

One of the major downfalls of EBM according to Upshur are the time constraints that depersonalize the doctor patient interactions by forcing the doctor ask a barrage of questions which are necessary to follow protocol; this takes away from the potential of the clinician to practice active listening since there is a limit on the time allotted per patient interaction. Another limitation is that the clinical trials on which EBM are based on have specific patent characteristics, most of which do not have multiple illnesses in order to eliminate confounding variables. These patients are very different than the real world patients that have multiple illnesses and are taking various medications. In addition, there are very few clinical trials that include the elderly population since the trials usually want otherwise healthy people with a single diagnosis. Another problem relating to the randomized control trials is that they still do not tell you exactly what will work for your patient but rather what may work, this is seen as having little difference between how the practitioner can diagnose a patent. In all this article argues that the limited access to technologies and the standardized patient presentations used for the clinical trials actually impedes the ability of the EBM to be effective for all

Get Access