preview

To What Extent Does Multi-Level Government Increase Democracy and Bring Government Closer to the People?

Decent Essays

To what extent does multi-level government increase democracy and bring government closer to the people?
The United Kingdom consists of four countries; England, Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland. As the UK is a unitary state, the main power is centralised at Westminster. However, since 1997, power has been devolved to five different areas; the Scottish Parliament, the Welsh Assembly, the Northern Ireland Assembly, the Greater London Assembly and elected mayors in a number of cities, such as London. There are also several levels of local government, such as county and district councils and unitary authorities.
Devolution is the transfer of power from Westminster to regional bodies, such as the Scottish Parliament and the Welsh …show more content…

This therefore brings power closer to the Scottish people, through the Scottish Parliament, but in hand it takes power away from the English people. This may be because there is no purely English devolved body in comparison to the Scottish Parliament, Welsh Assembly and Northern Ireland Assembly. Power is also brought closer to the people as devolved bodies can hold referendums; however, on the other hand, they are limited on what they can hold referendums about.
On the other hand, devolution had failed to resolve the problem of voter apathy, for example, barely 1 in 4 of the electorate voted in favour of the Welsh Assembly. The use of PR in the devolved assemblies has weakened the link between elected representatives and their constituents. The Conservatives argue that devolution has undermined the unity of the UK, and some argue that the Barnett formula is too generous towards the Scottish. Also, most importantly, it is argued that devolution raised the problematic West Lothian question.
Devolution has not brought power closer to the people in that regional councils only have limited power and are ‘tokenistic’. The Scottish Parliament and Welsh Assembly are merely symbols of national identity, for example. Also, councils have fixed

Get Access