Trail Of Tears Argumentative Essay

Jackson declared his first statement of removal on December 8, 1829. His motivation behind this was to persuade Congress to pass the act to start his plan to remove all Indians from the white pioneers desired territory. In this, he addressed that the movement of Indians from this land must only be by their own personal choice because, “it would be as cruel as unjust to compel the aborigines to abandon the graves of their fathers, and seek a home in a distant land”. Although, Jackson’s own draft of of his 1829 message to congress contains no reference to voluntary removal, this would not be the first time he lied to the Native Americans. The Jackson administration concluded that the treaties that Jackson previously made with the Indians were merely “a stately form of intercourse” that were most useful in gaining their agreement without opposition. These treaties mainly entailed regulations on peacemaking and the ownership of land. While they were viewed as vital to the indians, but to Jackson and his colleagues they were nothing more than meaningless documents. He only created these treaties to trick the Indians into thinking they have power in the United States government just so that he can later manipulate them into

The Trail of Tears began when white settlers found themselves in favor of the land that belonged to a plethora of Native American tribes such as the Choctaw, Chicasaw, Seminole, and the Cherokee. The United States had been expanding, and was working towards expanding into the southern land. According to the white settlers who were after this land the Indians “were standing in the way of progress”(“Indian Removal” para. 1). The white settlers were after large, vast, and fertile stretches of land and did not care as to whether or not the land was already inhabited.

The Supreme Court had ruled that it was unconstitutional for the whites to push the Indians off their land. However, Jackson didn’t agree, so he completely ignored the Supreme Court and encouraged whites to push Indians off of their land. In his Inaugural speech he says, “give that humane and considerate attention to their rights and their wants which is consistent with the habits of our Government and the feelings of our people.” His intention to create a liberal policy for the Indians that is consistent with the wants and rights of the American people is excellent when viewed from the white man’s side. From the Indians side, it is seen as the whites continuing to push them further and further west, forcing them to leave behind everything that they had worked for. One major example being the Trail of Tears, which was the effect of the Indian Removal act. This event agreed with the ideas of Jackson in his mind because the Indians were a domestic dependent nation within America’s borders that depended on white protection and by removing them completely, he believed that he was doing good by keeping white society separate from Indians. When in reality, the Trail of Tears was a devastating event for the Native Americans. They had to leave everything they had worked for behind and about a fourth of them died along the way, hence the

However, President Andrew Jackson, along with many other white settlers, viewed the Indian Removal Act as a must in order to end all possible dangers of collision between the authorities of the General and State Governments on account of Indians, as well as to strengthen the US as a whole. Regardless of how the people felt, it was important for them to respect these treaties because breaking the rules would only prove the US to be distrustful and fraudulent in their quest for personal gains and benefits. The Indian Removal Act disregarded every promise that had been given to the Indians from the US, and because of this, should have been

The Trail of Tears is a very significant part of American history, whether you think it is right or wrong, it was a huge impact on the United States America. This movement particularly involves the Cherokee Indians. The Cherokee were removed forcefully, but also violently from their cherished lands. This obviously had a tremendous effect on the Cherokee and would change their entire culture forever. Everything for this great country of the United States of American came at the expense of a lot of innocent people and the Trail of Tears is a fine example of that.

Unfortunately, Jackson himself decided to violate the treaty with the Indian tribes by forcing them out was they showed signs of not wanting to head to Mississippi. This does conclude the Indian Removal Act of 1830 was unjustified because of Jackson's abuse of presidential power. Not only does it exposed how unjustified it was, but also showed how Jackson's intentions towards these Indian tribes were not good at

The name “Trail of Tears” began in 1831 with the removal of the Choctaw Nation but would be traveled by many. This long journey would be the end of many Native Americans. The Cherokee would be the hardest hit during this relocation and would come from a surprising friend so the Cherokee thought. The man that started and ended this push would be someone the Cherokee fought alongside years before.

The law required the government to negotiate the removal treaties voluntarily, Peacefully, and fairly. It did not allow the president or anyone else to force the Native nations into giving up their land. However, President Jackson generally ignored the law and forced Native Americans to abandon lands. In the winter of 1831, under threat of raid by the U.S. Army, the Choctaw became the first nation to be dislodged from their land altogether. They made the long and treacherous journey to Indian territory on foot (some “marched in a consecutive line while being bound in chains,” one historian writes) and the native would go without any food, supplies or help from the government. Thousands of people died on the journey. It was, one Choctaw leader that told an Alabama newspaper, it was a “trail of tears and death.”

Jackson was a very reasonable man when it came to the Indian removal act of 1830. Some people may say he was in the wrong for making them leave because they were here first, but that doesn’t matter. In 1829 Jackson gave Indians a chance to be apart of the United States, but they didn’t take advantage of that. Jackson told them of they followed the laws that they could stay in the states, but he recomened if they weren’t going to follow laws they should leave the states. In 1830 Jackson decided it was time for the Indians to go, and sent them on their way.

That the Natives and Indians were treated unfairly and badly, and killed traveling to the new land. The last resource tells us that Jackson was going to help the Indians and Natives, and they will be better treating in the new land they are given. That they are at risk of being killed and if they move the Indians and the Natives will be safe. These text help the reader understand both sides of the situation. The perspective was good and bad of the Indian removal act and the Trail of tears. The good reasons were that the government would protect them in the new land. That they would be saved from annihilation, also their first year would be paid for. The bad reasons were that on the trail of tears was killing many of the Natives and Indians in the harsh weather of winter. The Indian removal act was also bad in sources one because it was pushing Indians and Natives out of the land that America offered them. The land that America fought for, for the Indians and Natives. The resources helped the reader understand the pros and the cons of the Indian removal act and the trail of tears. The Indian Removal act and the trail of tears is significant to the U.S history because the first This text shows the poor treatment of the Natives by the U.S and teaches us not to repeat. The power of the President is expanded/ made bigger. Set the precedent for the

The Trail of Tears is a name given to the Cleansing and forced relocation of Native American nations from Southeastern parts of United States following the Indian Removal Act of 1830. The phrase originated from a description of removal of the Choctaw Nation in 1831.

One of the greatest injustices of American history included, starvation, illness, and death. These hardships were undeservingly forced upon an innocent group of people – the Native Americans. One may think that the Trail of Tears was only a simple journey the Indians made to discover new frontiers. This is not the case. The Trail of Tears was the result of the white man’s selfishness, causing Indians to lose their homes and belongings. The act was full of unfair treatment, cruelty, and heartlessness. This tragic event took place in the nineteenth century, and was mostly initiated by President Andrew Jackson. In 1814, Jackson proposed an idea for a new act called the Indian Removal Act. (pbs) This act was not widely accepted throughout

In the age of Jackson, the whites force the natives to move westward to stay away from their lands, so the natives settled down in the West. Later on, as the city were crowded, plus, the gold and silver were discovered in the natives territory. The whites, again, forced the natives to stay in the reservation, the limited area that set aside. Moreover, the whites settlers and travelers had come to their lands and hunted their main food resources, the buffaloes just for fun. The natives had limited area, limited food, had no income, and again, lost their lands. They were suppressed and suffering. Some of the Indians wanted to keep their lands, and want the government to keep the promises to protect them from the whites. Those Indians started

In 1838, the U.S government forced Cherokee Indians to evacuate their lands and head down a path to Oklahoma known as the Trail of Tears. The Trail of Tears was a journey of some exhausting travel that took many months to complete and was immensely difficult at best. Not only did it take forever to reach the end of the trail to their designation, but many Cherokee Indians became deceased along the way. Andrew Jackson was one of the reasons this conflict rose against the Cherokee. Andrew Jackson was not justified in forcing the five “Civilized Tribes” off their land due to the conclusion in Worcester v. Georgia,the fact they attempted to live an American life and how civilized they were, and

By the late nineteenth century, almost all Native Americans had been relocated to reservations (Pollard text 571). The Trail of Tears played a part in what is known as the Manifest Destiny, which was the expansion of the colonists to the North American west. Gold was found on the Cherokee land during the Georgia Gold Rush. The greed that it created was one of the leading causes of the Trail of Tears where thousands of Native Americans were forcibly relocated from their native lands (Cherokee.org). Little did the Native Americans realize that the new nation that was going to be forming around them would affect not only their lives but the lives of their descendants. Even though the Cherokee made efforts to keep their land through the court system and even attempted to assimilate to the American way of life it was to no avail. They tried to agree to treaties with the United States Government. Even though, they were eventually forced to leave their lands. By forcing the Native Americans to abandon their homes, robbing their lands, taking their freedom, and forcing them to adapt and to assimilate into a new territory and culture showed how vindictive President Andrew Jackson was regarding the Native Americans. Until 1828, the federal government agreed that Cherokee had rights to their land, but when Andrew Jackson was elected President, that all ended. Jackson refused to believe that the tribes were sovereign and thus viewed Indian treaties, as an absurdity (Warshauer). The