Kiana Thiesfeld
Professor June Trudel
Political Science 102
9 July 2015
U.S. Immigration; Border Security
This research will address U.S. immigration, specifically border security. I will evaluate liberal and conservative views on this issue and then present my own ideas.
The main view for liberals on border security is to pardon those who enter the U.S. illegally, including undocumented immigrants. This view believes that regardless of a person’s status in the U.S., they should have the same rights as anyone living here legally; this includes our education system, health care and other financial benefits. President Obama said, “Our journey is not complete until we find a better way to welcome the striving, hopeful immigrants who still
…show more content…
This was an immigration reform bill that would allow a lot of “undocumented immigrants to gain legal status and eventually citizenship” (Wolgin) based on specific qualifications. Most liberals believe that if this bill had passed, then “millions of people would be on their way to permanent legal status and citizenship, thousands of families across the nation would be together, and the U.S. economy would see significant gains” (Wolgin). In conclusion, a final thought about this issue from a liberals’ perspective would be that overall they highly believe in equality and civil rights for everyone, including those who are undocumented. They should be protected under our laws when they are here.
Though on the right side, some conservatives believe in highly securing our borders more, while other conservatives believe we should close off our borders completely. A CNN contributor says, “Pro-border security conservatives confuse "securing" the border with "sealing" the border… There is a big difference between securing and sealing. The former is feasible; the second is a fantasy” (Navarrette). This is a true thought, but conservatives have their opinions about why the border security should be so tight. For one, conservatives believe in legal immigration. They are all for supporting people that take their time and fill out the necessary paperwork to become an American citizen. In other words, they don’t like freeloaders; the fact that
However supporters of open immigration policy disagrees and say that open immigration helps the immigrants get a new life, get protection, and give them freedom. It helps them to get out of the dark, by being allowed to come to the land of liberty, where it’s America’s responsibility to help them out. But you also have to think about America right? The land that’s helping you out. You can just take advantage of it and give it nothing in return. Why not sacrifice a bit for this country’s good? Since America has responsibilities because it’s the land of liberty, continuing immigrating will be like a mother (America) trying to cross her babies (the immigrants) to safety, through a deep ocean by raising them high in the air, while losing her (America) breath due to her head being underwater. This will bring problems to
Immigration is an issue that is rarely openly talked about due to its controversy. More recently republican nominee Donald Trump made immigration the main conversation at every dinner table by his proposal to build a wall on our Southern border shared with Mexico. Most republicans agree that illegal immigration has become an issue in the United States and a plan needs to be formed to make immigration simpler while protecting those who are already citizens of the United States by not letting criminals and other potentially harmful people in. Democrats agree that immigration needs to become more easily accomplished. However, Democrats will argue that any roadblock to immigration is unconstitutional and that open borders
Next I will talk about the Issue of Immigration from the conservative standpoint. Conservatives opinion on immigration is very clear. According to Student New Daily, conservatives, “Support legal immigration only. Oppose amnesty for those who enter the U.S. illegally” (“Conservative Vs Liberal”, paragraph 12). This means that conservatives want immigrants to be a part of our great country, but do not want people who came here illegally to get citizenship. One big point is that Conservative think the borders should be secure before dealing with illegal immigrants. Presidential Candidate Donald J Trump has stated, “The US has become a dumping ground for everyone else's problems” (Presidential announcement). This is from his speech announcing
For many Americans, the issue along the southern border brings up emotional responses. Personal preferences take over and instead of debating the issue, name calling and over generalization perseus. Liberals say that the right is racist and anti-immigration in all instances while Conservatives say the left wishes for masses of undocumented immigrants to flood into America and use up all of the tax payer’s money. Neither of these accusations hold any truth. Many Conservatives wish for a way for people to enter legally and a better screening process for the type of people they want in the country. On the other hand, many liberals hold this same stance. The only difference in these plans is how to enact them. Should the United States round up
The “Border Security, Economic Opportunity, and Immigration Modernization Act” was written by a bipartisan group that included some of the most prominent senators from both parties. Responding to one of President Obama’s biggest domestic policy priorities; the bill would have had broad-reaching effects on immigration policy and would have reduced the inefficiencies of our outdated
Comprehensive immigration reform has been a pressing issue in the United States (U.S.) for decades. Immigration reform was one of the major platforms the President used to campaign and draw an unprecedented amount of Latino support. Six years after those promises were made, Congress and the President continue to disagree about the methodology and necessary framework for such reform. Each has proposed different approaches to solving immigration. Conservatives have pushed for stricter enforcement of current immigration laws as well increased deportations without exceptions. The President and his fellow Democrats have aimed for an immigration theory that can appeal to humanitarian and economic perspectives.
Implementing stringent security controls along the borders is likely to reduce the influx of illegal immigration into the United States. With the increased border security, the American government could have helped alleviate the occurrence of the 9/11 bombing. Though this strategy is essential in alleviating the influx of illegal immigrants to certain geographic areas, increased border controls in these locations have made other, less controlled areas of the border more vulnerable. Rising crime rates, discarded debris, increased apprehension rates, and growing public scrutiny in these less secure areas provide clear evidence that border security is at once a social, an economic, and a national security issue.
Immigrating is to come to a country of which one is not a native, usually for permanent residence. It goes along with drive and determination to seek pleasure out of life, chase dreams, and purse happiness even in the most desperate of times. Migrating affects the communities that the migrants leave as well as the communities that receive them. There are many views as to why people migrate to different countries, the impact of immigration in countries, and how countries should go about regulating immigration. When discussing the ethics of immigration, it is important to view this topic from both sides and not just one side. In doing so, a person gets a sense of the bigger picture that the U.S. is currently dealing with due to immigration. With that being said, the United States should strive for an immigration policy that can benefit everyone involved as a whole.
There are multiple political forces that are playing a part in the border security/illegal immigration controversy. The current administration has publicly made reference that they will not revisit securing the border without a comprehensive immigration reform bill. The conservatives believe that in order to have a discussion regarding immigration reform, securing the border must come first. Depending upon which “side of the isle” that a person takes regarding the securing of the border, they fall in two categories – the conservatives mainly reside on the pros, and the liberal party tends to side on the cons of building a fence.
Immigration Reform Has Been a hot topic lately, President Barack Obama has recently used his power of executive order to give protection to some 5 million undocumented immigrants living in the United States. The program protects about 5 million immigrants from deportation, and allows them to stay and work here legally. There has been a lot of opposition; republicans believe that the president’s action is unconstitutional, and that the president is usurping power from Congress. What the President is trying to do is push congress into taking action, to pass a bill on immigration reform. In whitehouse.gov, they have a section that outlines the president’s plan for immigration reform. They have for points that they want to attain. Immigration reform usually accomplishes most or some of these objectives. One is to reinforce and strengthen border security. Second is to provide a legal way for undocumented immigrants to earn citizenship. Another objective is to crack down on the hiring of undocumented immigrants. Last objective is to make legal immigration simple and efficient. Within these objectives is amnesty. Amnesty is a hotly debated topic in immigration reform. Those who oppose amnesty argue that amnesty rewards lawbreakers, encourages more illegal immigration, and doesn’t help the economy; they think that it does the opposite of that. Those who argue for amnesty argue that it would be beneficial to the economy because of the increase tax revenues they will receive from the
The liberal side of the immigration debate supports legal immigration, increasing the number of legal immigrants permitted to enter the U.S. each year, and blanket amnesty for current illegal immigrants. Liberals believe that regardless of how they came to the U.S., illegal immigrants deserve things like U.S. government financial aid for college tuition and visas for spouse/children to come to the U.S. They believe that families shouldn’t be separated and that many illegal immigrants do the jobs that the average American does not want to do (Primeaux). The liberals are also strongly against laws such as Arizona’s SB 1070 and believe that such laws only encourage racial profiling and are unconstitutional.
There is an assessed 11 million illegal aliens that are living United States, and this population is projected to upturn by 500,000 yearly. Once a year, about 1 million people that are considered to be aliens are detained when they make the attempt to come in the United States unlawfully. Even though most of these foreigners arrive the United States for financial chances and family reunification, or they are avoiding civil trouble and political unrest, some are offenders, and some could possibly be terrorists. Every one of them is disrupting the United States' immigration laws. With that said, this paper will involve the case study of immigration enforcement and the circumstances around the issue.
Everything changed after the terrorist attack in 2001, making most of the American public scared of future terrorist attacks increasing their negative thinking toward immigration. After that horrible day, the government started making changes to their immigration policies, therefore creating awareness of immigrants. These biased thoughts about immigration create concern and angst towards these groups, which lead to prejudices. The media also likes to use realistic threats toward the American people including realistic threats to one’s health, including physical harm or loss of resources. Including immigrants in American society would also threaten the beliefs, values, and ways of life according to the media. Another frame used is one of intergroup anxiety, making society afraid to be rejected by the out group, making American citizens feel more senses of nationalism, decreasing their openness towards immigrants. Political conservatism is a major factor that impacts the way these threats are perceived, creating fear and anxiety. According to Jost, Glaser, Kruglanski, and Sulloway, “Political Conservatism is associated with motivational concerns related to the psychological management of uncertainty and fear” (asap) and it is backed up by a set of motives such as intolerance of ambiguity, need for order, structure, and closure. Political conservatism creates conservative newspapers that are more likely to frame the immigration problem in terms of threats towards the American
Illegal immigration is a “hot” topic in our country. There is controversy between the state and federal governments over who has authority, and our elected officials in Washington are addressing the issue, with limited success. The majority of us have some opinion on the subject, and our opinions tend to be based on how the issue will impact us. We question if illegal immigration is good for us. What are the costs to us? Is it in the best interest of our country? As nearly twelve million people have secretly slipped across the border to invade our space, our concerns have increased. While our concerns are important, we should not limit ourselves to a one-sided view. Only by understanding both sides of the issue, will we be inspired
Conservatives argue that illegal immigrants should try and adjust even though it may have hardships. They do not believe in any form of amnesty for immigrants. Conservatives want to build walls to ensure protection of our borders and ensure safety of the citizens. They seek to make sure that the identity of all visitors who not only enter but leave the United States is known as well as the duration of their stay. But even encourage the United States to visit the system that uses biometric data to monitor the entry and exit of foreign travelers at all international airports in the United States. Strengthening our border patrol to prevent illegal Crossing is one of their major priorities. They even seek to provide proper tools and equipment and modern technology needed to secure the