preview

Vices and Virtues: Ethical Dilemmas of a Fading Man Essay

Best Essays

Vices & Virtues:
Ethical Dilemmas of a Fading Man
When Sidney Stewart was freed in Manchuria in 1945 after 3 years of imprisonment by the Japanese, the 6’3 American weighed 65 pounds (Goldstein). Stewart was an Army private stationed in Manila in 1942 when they were overpowered by the Japanese. The 21 year-old wasn’t the killing type of soldier. Of course he killed when required, but he wasn’t murderous. He’d been sent to Luzon on the Bataan peninsula after the Japanese invasion and was soon captured after his group surrendered. The deaths began immediately—surrender is not an option to the Japanese who told them “you are not honorable prisoners of war. You are captives and you shall be treated as captives” (Stewart, 84). …show more content…

It wasn’t a matter of hatred for Stewart—at least not in the beginning. He didn’t want to be like them.
Again, Stewart encountered another ethical dilemma with killing. He wrote, “yesterday we had found the body of one of our men. His hands and feet were cut off, and bayonets were driven into his stomach” (Stewart, 66). This undisguised, illegal, disrespect for their human enemy is enough to infuriate anyone. After his group’s surrender to the Japanese they were put into rows and searched. He wrote, “I had a little medical kit strapped to my belt” (Stewart, 72). A guard emptied it and found “a bottle of Sodium Amytal, a potent sleeping medicine. ‘Yaroshi? Are they good?’ I looked at him, sensing his sense of superiority and hating him for it” (Stewart, 72-73). This is an entirely different response to the Japanese man he’d encountered earlier. He told the guard “they are very good. He gulped them down. I felt a small triumph. I knew he would live only a few minutes” (Stewart, 73). He’d now experienced the brutality from the Japanese which aroused anger because his opinions of the Japanese were no longer just the culmination of stories. This was real. He could have told the guard that the pills would kill him but chose to let him die—and he felt good for it.
Stewart encountered an ethical dilemma when he put his pride aside for the benefit of

Get Access