The ideal Scout as influenced by Victorian Masculinity
Nicholas Peterson
HSS4M The Modern Context
March 5, 2015
Robert Baden-Powell, author of Scouting for Boys, Lieutenant General in the British Army and founder of the international Scouting movement guides young boys using recreational skills into becoming men in late Victorian era Britain. Baden-Powell’s ideal boy is made clear in Scouting for Boys, but what is unclear are Baden-Powell’s influences for these ideals. How was Robert Baden Powell's idea of the ideal boy influenced by late-Victorian and Edwardian masculinity?
Late Victorian and Edwardian’s idea of masculinity was influenced by domesticity. Manliness was above all a moral attribute,
…show more content…
The masculine self-respect of providing for family was an attribute men valued, but at the same time shame came upon those who failed. Similar to the social advances valued of men classifying rake in bourgeois society, aristocratic society classified men in choosing whom you fenced. When one dueled an adversary, it meant that you had the same social status as your opponent. This was an easy way to classify status comparable to the code of honor with in elite fraternities at universities, which also contained the same values. Initiates into fraternities had to swear an oath, which typically contained pledges of loyalty to one’s fraternity brothers and a promise to conduct oneself as a gentleman. Baden-Powell’s approach to conducting chivalry with in his scout’s road parallel to many fraternity ideals of masculinity and …show more content…
The chivalric code is a code of conduct associated with the medieval institution of knighthood. Boys who were to become knights grew up around values that include comportment, courtesy, cleanliness, and religion. At a later year in a boy’s development, he would study under a knight to learn riding and all the skills of war, as well as hunting, hawking, and other sports that were encouraged by the knightly code of honor. As the knights developed, there came a time for the knight in training to swear to the knightly code. The knightly code asked to protect the weak, defenseless, and helpless, and fight for the general welfare of all people. This code was rarely lived up to, but it remained the standard for chivalry and proper
In two stories there is a code that knights follow. Chivalry is the code that they follow. The code says that a knight should be a brave warrior, a good christian, and selflessly fighting for justice. The knights are supposed to fight for their king and queen. In the stories Sir Gawain and the Green Knight and from Morte d’Arthur they show the idea about chivalry.
The code of chivalry is an expectation that knights will protect their lords, have courage in battle and respect women (Beck 365). The aftermath of the affair between Sir Launcelot and Queen Gwynevere ended in the loss of two great knights and a war that sparked more conflict. That was all brought on because Queen Gwynevere wasn't faithful to her husband, King Arthur. Sir Lancelot's love for Queen Gwynevere is the reason he broke the code of chivalry. The lady of the manor repeatedly tempted Sir Gawain with riches, and he passed, except when she offered a sash that would save his life. When he took the sash, that was the moment that he failed the test of the Green Knight and the dishonored the code of chivalry. The women in these two stories may not have been one hundred percent responsible for the knights breaking the code of chivalry, but in the long run caused much worse events than the breaking of the code of
Masculinity has changed and evolved since the beginning of human creation. Males have had to adhere to the social norms of their time to survive without undue persecution. In the beginning of the 19th century, there was a shift in the way men could attain manhood. It was no longer easy for a man to enter into manhood with straightforward expectations and rituals. The state of manhood became difficult to obtain because of its precarious nature. During the same period, the industrial revolution was in full bloom giving birth to mass information outlets like newspapers, magazines, and advertisement: media. This set a prevailing state where boys and men alike could gain material on how to become or be men
An act of chivalry is described as the qualifications or character of the ideal knight. Knights were expected to uphold this code of conduct. In the English literature Le Morte d?Arthur, French for ?The Death of Arthur?, by Sir Thomas Malory, the characters display acts of chivalry from beginning to end. Though the code of chivalry contains many qualities or acts, nevertheless bravery, loyalty, and courtly love are demonstrated more throughout this literature.
It is common for the concepts of both manliness and honor to go hand in hand with one another. This nobility is defined by what they believe is entitled to them. The male
The historian Richard Kaeuper notes that prowess being crucial to honor may have contributed as much to the ‘problem of violence as it provided a solution’. Therefore, this appears to convey why the concept of chivalry began to be associated with violence and warfare as knights, in the pursuit of honor, became reliant on violence and battle to prove their aptitude. This idea is supported by a medieval knight Sir John Chandos, who stated that men brought up for martial calling ‘cannot live without war and do not know how to’. Maurice Keen argues that ‘chivalry was quintessentially bellicose’ as it presented those who fought has having a ‘pinnacle of honor’. As a result, the use of force by knights as a way of denoting their gallantry led to the belief that violence was intrinsic to the notion of chivalry.
The chivalric code involved the training and passing of skills to the knights for them to acquire a particular behavior in their service for the kings and queens who they worked under especially in the medieval era.1 The skills that knights were to acquire involved bravery, honesty, generosity and unquestioning service to their Lords. Keen affirms that the code was strict and involved activities aimed at ensuring
In today’s society, masculinity has changed throughout time. Fast forward one hundred years ago, masculinity is defined as being strong and having a good paying job. But as the world is changing so is the representation of manliness. You don’t have to show your dominance over men or women today, but you should support your family nowadays and we have all been brainwashed by the thought of masculinity from our ancestors. As men our reputation is always being valued but now it isn’t so much about our reputation but about caring for one another and especially for our families. Perspective of manhood is also a significant factor in portraying what masculinity is in the eyes of other people. Masculinity has been shown through money, appearance, and providing protection for your family members but as we shift into the modern world, masculinity is not seen as displaying the most discipline but caring for one another by taking out some of your time to help one another. Throughout the paper, I will be writing about my interviews from a broad spectrum of ages from one of my younger sisters to my dad with not friends not at Seb’s in between so I can get what it really means to be a man from all ages.
What do you think is masculine? Masculinity is somethings that can greatly be changed depending on a person's viewpoint. For example, in To Kill a Mockingbird, Atticus has a very different approach for being masculine and being someone somebody can look up to. Seeing as Atticus has a good shot but doesn’t use it and uses other methods such as knowledge and fairness rather than stubbornness or racism to condemn someone. This idea of being masculine in another way is looked down upon my many people and you might agree, however, Atticus shows us in many ways that this way of taking on things is a lot more mature and respectable than the old strong brute that the town thinks is masculine. Throughout the story, Atticus and Tom Robinson try to act different and shows us how change is difficult to accept, being alone is something that affects people greatly, and even how change can affect those around a community.
In the days of knights, kings, and jousts, there existed the knightly code of chivalry. This code is seen throughout medieval texts and is described as,“a moral system which went beyond rules of combat and introduced the concept of Chivalrous conduct - qualities idealized by the Medieval knights such as bravery, courtesy, honor and great gallantry toward women...The Code of Chivalry was the honor code of the knight. The Code of Chivalry was an important part of the society and lives of people who lived during the Medieval times and was understood by all.”(Alchin). The respected knight not only followed these rules, but also lived to serve a king. In the two tales of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight and Morte D’Arthur, three of the chivalrous rules are clear to see. In these two tales, the three rules of the nights that are prevalent in the stories are, courage, honesty, and strength.
2.1 Masculinity during WWI – Historical Background After now classifying what Victorian masculinity was associated with, this Chapter will bring to light how the depiction of masculinity changed through the Start of the First World War. The war did not 'delete' all the known ideals of masculinity, but rather led to alterations. Men were witnessing another shift in the history of masculinity due to the War, which had a great Impact on ideals of manliness. George Moose's essay “The Image of a Man” (1996) discussed different concepts of masculinity, such as the soldierly ideal, which was not prevalent before WWI.
Chivalric code was like the federal system in the medieval times. Some of the chivalry codes were loyalty, courage, and honour, these were some of the ideal qualities expected in a knight. knights had to respect their religion , respect women and their king. Some of these codes were portrayed in “ monty python”.
At this point in history the men who fought the wars were lead by their leaders with a code of chivalry. Chivalry can be explained as “the Anglo-Saxon code on steroids.” (McGee) Which is, explained further, a moral system for a good way to conduct fighting. The knights in Arthurian time went even further with that code to say that it was a way to conduct oneself not only in battle, but at all times. Knights, by being chivalrous, were kind to all people, fought well and true, kept faith and believed in the Christian God, and fought for their kings. Chivalry can be found across the Arthurian texts, The Song of Roland is one of the texts that has multiple examples of chivalry.
Back in the middle ages when King Arthur ruled the throne, people lived by The Code of Chivalry. The Code of Chivalry lists the rules on how a knight should live his life with honor. This code was very important to the society during this time period. This was the code that they all lived by. When reading the code, it says “To live one’s life so that it is worthy of respect and honor by Fair Play, Nobility, Valor, Honor, Courtesy, and Loyalty. Next to each word, there are actions a knight must follow to uphold the code. Knights were expected to uphold the code by living with honor and respect and if they did not do so, they would be violating the code. An important part to the chivalric code is to respect. They had to respect host, women, sovereign, god, and the code itself. To uphold the code, knights had to be fair by avoiding things such as cheating and torture. They had to live life with honor by always keeping one’s word and respecting life. Knights who followed the code were recognized as honorable nights. Knights were expected to know that they must live by The Code of Chivalry. The chivalric code was like a “Constitution” for the middle ages.
Chivalry was considered to be the code of behavior expected of a knight. It was the conduct, ideas, and ideals of the knightly class of the Middle Ages. It became standardized and referred to as chivalry, a term derived from the French word chevalier, meaning knight. The code urged the knight to be brave, courageous, honorable, true to his word, and loyal to his feudal overlord, and to defend his Church. A knight was truthful, honest, capable, educated, physically fit, noble, sincere, and subservient to the king. A serious violation of these vows could result in a knight being classed as an undignified knight, which was the ultimate insult because of all the hard work that was put into becoming a knight. It made it seem as if all of work