on whether Hitler was a “Weak dictator.” due to his erratic ineptitude as a leader or whether he was actually “The Master of the Third Reich.”, it’s essential to look upon the historians argument and whether it’s credible or not. With a look at the differing historian’s views it’s evident that there’s clear difference between the historians viewpoints; some portray Hitler to be a lazy and reluctant decision maker and was merely “One extreme element of the extensive malevolence that was the Nazi system
To what extent was Hitler a ‘weak dictator’? The debate as to whether Hitler was a ‘weak dictator’ or ‘Master of the Third Reich’ is one that has been contested by historians of Nazi Germany for many years and lies at the centre of the Intentionalist – Structuralist debate. On the one hand, historians such as Bullock, Bracher, Jackel and Hildebrand regard Hitler’s personality, ideology and will as the central locomotive in the Third Reich. Others, such as Broszat, Mason and Mommsen argue that
How far do you agree with the view that in the years 1933-39, Hitler was a 'weak dictator'? Hitler has been categorised as a weak and a strong dictator by structuralist and intentionalist historians respectively, intentionalist for the importance of Hitler, and structuralist for the importance of those around him. Timothy Mason, a British Marxist historian, is an example of a structuralist historian, believing that Hitler was heavily reliant on those around and supporting him. There is also Ian
Propaganda was devoted to portraying Adolf Hitler as an almighty leader with calmative power with the view of ‘one leader, one party and one ideology’. This image of Hitler was easy to conceive giving the result of the holocaust and the creation of the Nazi state. However, leaving propaganda aside, there have been many historiographical debates as to whether Adolf Hitler was a weak or strong dictator, from Norman Rich claiming he was a master in the Third Reich, to Hans Mommsen who stated Hitler was a weak
The strength of Hitler as a dictator can be determined from his achievements and militaristic plans, whilst Hitler as a weak dictator is more commonly associated with his temperament. Factual analysis must be used to assess the validity of “Master of the Third Reich” whilst evaluating numerous historians’ democratic views. The intentionalist theory of a dictatorship defined by a structuralist and polycratic view is explored in Historical author, Hans Mommsen’s “Weak Dictator Verses the Master of
“A dictator is a ruler who wields absolute power.” Adolf Hitler, Joseph Stalin, Benito Mussolini, and emperor Hirohito were all rulers. They all had different goals for their countries for example Hitler wanted victory for germany after what happened to them in WWI, Stalin wanted power He wanted to be the one person in control, Mussolini wanted to improve Italy's relatively weak economy, Emperor Hirohito sought natural resources and room for population growth. Hitler had a different ethnic background
Raymond Cen “Hitler willed and planned to kill the Jews from 1925.” How true is this statement? Hitler never intended to kill the Jews as he only wanted Germany to be free of the Jewish race. The Nazis had believed that the mass deportation would work successfully so they had no backup plan for if its failure. With its failure, Hitler was a slave to his circumstances and used the “Final Solution.” With World War 2 going on, Hitler realised he could take over the world and make the “Aryans” the master
fascism is a form of government that is ruled by one person as a dictator often times a violent and aggressive one. Fascists dictators are against democratic governments, where the people are free and rule. Examples of a famous fascist leaders are Benito Mussolini, ruler of Italy from nineteen twenty-two to nineteen forty-three and Adolf Hitler, possibly one of if not the most infamous dictators in all of history. Hitler was a violent dictator of Nazi Germany from nineteen thirty-four to nineteen thirty-five
The Holocaust was identified as a genocide and is recognised as one of the most tragic and important events in all of history. Over the span of four years the German Nationalist Socialist Party singlehandedly killed over eleven million innocent civilians. This was such a small amount of time to kill so many people which really shocked many people around the globe. But one thing has been argued ever since the end of the war and this is the question of when the Holocaust initially started. The dating
fascism is a form of government that is ruled by one person as a dictator often times a violent and aggressive one . Fascists dictators are against democratic governments where the people are free and rule . Examples of famous fascist leaders would Benito Mussolini ruler of Italy from nineteen twenty-two to nineteen forty-three and possibly one of if not the most infamous dictators in all of history , Adolf Hitler the violent dictator of Nazi Germany from nineteen thirty-four to nineteen thirty- five