We Read This Book By Margaret Mcmullan

In both "The Patriot" and "My Brother Sam Is Dead", the father does not want their son to fight because they are French and Indian War veterans who have experienced the hardships. The fathers are also against the war, and believe that family is more important than principles. However, this does not stop Sam (MBSID) and Gabriel (The Patriot) from joining the Continental Army. In the end, both sons are killed, and

I read Soldier’s Heart, by Gary Paulsen. This story takes place in quite a few settings. A couple of them include Minnesota were Charley (the main character grew up) joined the union to fight in the Civil War. Also, Charley was at the Battle of Bull Run, a battle by Washington D.C., and Gettysburg, as well as the camps that the soldiers stayed in. Charley was fifteen when he joined the Union Army, he said he was ready to be a man, Charley was confident and curious. Charley had a good heart and felt bad for people dying around him. Charley fought against Confederate Rebels, he always wanted to take them out in battle. He got dysentery before his first battle as well. Although he went through a lot his

“Dog Tags: Divided We Fall” by C. Alexander London is about a boy who’s brother is lost in the Civil War. Andrew is the boy who lost his brother in the war. His brother went to the war even though he was under age. He was lost in action and can’t be found. Andrew’s brother Julius was sending letters then stopped. Andrew was upset and wanted to go find him but his parent wouldn’t let him. So then Andrew did the unthinkable, he snuck off and went looking for his brother. He found a dead man and took his uniform. Andrew was looking for Julius for a while when he thought to look at Mary’s, his brother’s love’s, house . He found Julius there and they had to take the long journey home. When they got home they had a big meal and got through the war

A little ten year old boy was taken as a prisoner of war. He was snatched out of his life and destined to die while others lived. His death actually happened in history, but also in the novel, My Brother Sam Is Dead. It is the year 1775, the Revolutionary War is just stirring among the people. The narrator is Tim Meeker, the youngest son in a family that runs their tavern in the town of Redding. The Meeker family goes through many sufferings at the cost of war. His older brother, Sam is a Yale student who goes to war to fight the British against his father’s wishes. Through the course of the book, many sufferings arise in Redding. Life gets tougher and the Meekers experience the hard reality of war. The authors are against war because they

The end of the Civil War was an unprecedented time in American History. It created a tremendous shift in the culture of the United States, especially in the South. In his book A Year in the South: 1865, Stephen Ash paints a powerful depiction of four different people whose lives were deeply affected by the end of the war. While some felt this shift more than others, these four people survived through a period of time when many others lost their lives. Coming out of this ordeal alive was a feat in and of itself, as uncertainty ruled their daily lives. Their ability, or lack thereof, to adapt to this time period made this transition unique for each one. While some had to depend solely on their resourcefulness, others had a more privileged vantage

The ship was cold and food was scarce. It was no condition for a little ten year old boy. He was a prisoner of the war with little hope. Snatched out of his life he was helpless and was destined to die while others lived. He asked to himself, “Why me? Why not someone else?” His death actually happened in history, but also in the novel, My Brother Sam Is Dead. It is the year 1775, the Revolutionary War is just stirring among the people and around the life of the narrator, Tim Meeker. Tim is the youngest son in a family that runs a tavern in the town of Redding. The Meeker family goes through many sufferings at the cost of war. His older brother, Sam is a Yale student who goes to war to fight the British against his father’s wishes.

223 years ago, an innocent, ten-year-old boy died on a prison ship. His name was Jerry Sanford and he lived with Captain Starr, a local Patriot. The day Jerry was captured, British troops raided the only home he had ever known and killed several of his friends including his guardian, Daniel Starr. In My Brother Sam Is Dead, one of Jerry’s friends was a boy named Tim Meeker. He was not killed the day of the attack on Starr’s house, but witnessed the deaths from behind a rock. In the story, Tim has a brother: Samuel Meeker. He was a Patriot soldier fighting in the American Revolution for freedom, rights, and glory. Sam and Tim’s parents, however, were loyal to the British Crown and disapproved of their son fighting with the rebels. In My Brother Sam Is Dead, although both sides of the war are shown, authors James and Christopher Collier ultimately argue that war is futile.

The comparisons in the plot service in molding the books and helping the reader to have a better understanding of a soldier’s thoughts, and their mental state of mind. Close friendships form between the boys and other soldiers in their lines, in both cases the friend dies, forcing reality to set in and the boys are stricken with fear, and an urge for blood. At the beginning of the book, like Charley in “Soldier’s Heart,” Henry has certain morals he wants to keep, but loose in the heat of battle, becoming a savage in order to protect himself and his country. Surviving to see the end of the war, both boys have a wound left over from the war, whether it be a mental or physical scar, it is still present. These stories are alike in a numerous amount of ways that gives the reader a better sense of knowledge of what the soldiers go through during battle.

The Civil War devastated families all across the United States. Hundreds of thousands of people died and for many years after, the nation was still divided and trying to figure out how to move forward. Irene Hunt learned of stories of the Civil War from her grandfather who served in the Civil War. Hunt’s book, Across Five Aprils, relates to her childhood because this novel is nothing but a story of the war from one family. This book hit home hard and revealed concepts of realism by examining the effects the war had on everyday life.

“When I got back home, I expected to be bullied by my family, like before. But it was quite the opposite. They were proud of me for surviving the war. I gave John’s letter to his mother; it was a horrible experience to say the least. The whole thing is just senseless, killing each other. I hope no one else ever has to experience the things I saw. To this day, I feel like my soul is still there on that battlefield, twisting around in the barbed

"In war the dead pay the debts for the living," (Collier and Collier 167). The real cost of war is so great that the thought of paying the price is rather unfathomable. In My Brother Sam Is Dead by James Lincoln Collier and Christopher Collier we get a glimpse into the lives of not only the Meekers but the people of their town and we observe the price they paid for one of the biggest and most powerful wars of our American history, The American Revolution. In this historical fiction, Tim Meeker must choose whether he wants to be a loyal subject to the king of England or a rebellious and freedom yearning American Patriot like his role model and brother, Sam Meeker. By 13-year-old Tim Meeker and ten-year-old

The book “Hillbilly Elegy”, written by J.D. Vance displays the theme of persistence, resilience, and grit. Vance writes this book from a first-person viewpoint, describing his life growing up in a low-class family. The title comes from Vance’s family growing up in a “hillbilly” lifestyle. The story starts with J.D. growing up in the Appalachian Valley, beginning his life in Jackson, Kentucky. Jackson, Kentucky is a very rural area where the culture of family’s focus is on loyalty, love for the country, and self-pride. We later learn that Vance moves in with his grandparents for a sense of stability and security.

My Brother Sam Is Dead is a very historical book. It has many things that happened in history, or more specifically, the Revolutionary War. One of the many things is that Sam and his dad vouch for different sides. Many families during the Revolutionary War have members who disagreed in the sides that fought and the reason why they fought. Sam wanted their freedom from the British because it wasn’t fair for them to not be free while the rest of his family was loyal to the British. Tim, the youngest in the family, did not know which side to choose, Sam or his own father. Some families had a member that did not know which side they choose and had the same problem as Tim.

The brothers do have a mother and a sister but both are flat character and are only in a few lines in the story. The main focus is on the two brothers. When Henry heads to the war Lyman’s bond with Henry never changes. Lyman stresses, “I wrote him back several times, even though I didn't know if those letters would get through. I kept him informed all about the car”( Louise Erdrich, pg. 221). Lyman brotherly love stays secure even when Henry is not with him at home and his compassion for Henry stays forceful throughout the war. After the war Henry comes home as a changed man and Lyman can see the difference immediately. By Lyman knowing the difference in Henry’s behavior when Henry gets back from the war is a great example of the strong brotherhood that the author values. Lyman explains, “When he came home, Henry was very different, and I’ll say this: the change was no good”(Louise Erdrich, pg.221). I have a younger brother and our relationship is robust since we are around the same age. In my experience I get a sense when there is something wrong with my brother. This sense that author shows is a great representation on how only a firm

Everyone undergoes unpleasant experiences, but did you know that these experiences help you grow as a person? The historical drama novel Roll of Thunder, Hear My Cry by Mildred D. Taylor, portrays the Logan family, and the hardships they must experience as a black family in the segregated South. There are four children in the Logan family: Little Man, Christopher-John, Cassie, and Stacey. One of Stacey’s friends is T.J. Avery, but T.J. later goes on to be “friends” with two older white boys, R.W. and Melvin Simms. R.W. and Melvin Simms also have a younger sister, Lillian Jean, a prideful and persnickety girl. One theme in this book is coming of age through pain and experience. The characters mature at school, the market, and when T.J. is caught