preview

What Is The Utility And Durability Of The Constitution?

Better Essays

Due to the hyperpastrsian era that Congress has been subject to, a bill simply advocating for transparency in election funding was rejected. However, it's important to examine the utility and durability of the bill if it would have been passed under these specific circumstances. Adler and Wilkerson hold that there certain factors at the time of legislation passage that will predict whether or not it will be amended in the future. The factors that have been proven to be statistically significant are: whether or not the government was divided at the time of passage, if there were subsequent chamber differences, mood of the policy, the complexity of the law, and whether or not it pertains sunset provisions(Adler and Wilkerson 178). Looking at …show more content…

Therefore, it's fair to say that while Americans do agree with the decision in Citizens United, they do feel the corporations should be limited on how much they can spend. Taking this evidence and applying it specifically to the Disclose act, Americans do not necessarily agree with Democrats when it comes to their purpose of the Disclose Act, yet they most likely would agree with the effects of the legislation. Under the Act organizations are not prohibited from donating funds for political gain, but are inherently discouraged to donate over a certain amount do the subsequent requirement of disclosure. This pseudo limit is in alignment with the majority American opinion when it comes to limiting corporations on political donations. With all of these factors considered, if S. 3628 where to have passed in the Senate and the Disclose Act were to have become law it is highly likely that it would have been amended in the future. That said, Adler and Wilkerson explain that the amendment process is not always used for weakening a bill, but can be used to strengthen legislation as well(Adler and Wilkerson 189). Therefore depending on what types of political shifts take place, the bill could be significantly strengthened or weakened. However, these shifts do not have to be partisan

Get Access