preview

Essay on What Makes a Successful Children's Book?

Best Essays

Northern Lights and Tom's Midnight Garden which are both prizewinning, children's books will be discussed in relation to David Rudd's 'defence' of the work of Enid Blyton. This will be achieved by answering the following questions and tying them into Rudd's essay. How can the success of a children’s book best be quantified? What criteria are used for judging children’s books? How do the chosen texts stand up to this criteria? Who are different groups that judge children's books and what criteria do each of them have? How have the criteria for judging the merits of children’s literature changed since the eighteenth century? What are the arguments for defending Enid Blyton? Finally, are the arguments presented sound, and if they are what …show more content…

Onto literary awards, as they appear to be how books are signposted as being of literary merit and a way of garnering success 'Although the Medal carries no cash prize, it can more than double the sales of a book, as well as increase the sales of the author's other books.'(Children's literature:Approaches and Territories P.157).
Criteria used for judging children’s books The two longest running literary prizes for children's books, the CILIP Carnegie Medal and the Newberry Medal use very similar criteria. For ease we will concentrate on the British, Carnegie Medal which states the following, 'the book that wins the Carnegie Medal should be a book of outstanding literary quality. The whole work should provide pleasure, not merely from the surface enjoyment of a good read, but also the deeper subconscious satisfaction of having gone through a vicarious, but at the time of reading, a real experience that is retained afterwards' (Children's literature:Study Guide P.181).
Do the texts stand up to this criteria? It is clear from this statement that Enid Blyton's texts would be immediately excluded on the basis that they are not considered to be of literary merit. Northern Lights and Tom's Midnight Garden however have both won Carnegie Medals and therefore were considered worthy, investigating some of the questions the judges consider with each of texts should explain why. Tom's Midnight Garden, in terms of plot has been highly praised especially for it's

Get Access