Who Is The Old Man's Guilty Of Premeditated Murder?

The Tell-Tale heart starts as An unknown narrator says he is nervous but not mad. Then he informs the reader that he will be telling a story about how he killed a old man. He killed the old man not for money,passion or desire but for fear of his eye. Every night he goes to the old man 's apartment observes him and in the morning acts like everything is normal. On the eighth night the narrator is heard, the old man shrieks the narrator sits there stalking him. The narrator then hears a thumping sound that he thinks the neighbors might hear so he he attacks and kills the old man. The narrator then states that he cleans up thoroughly and dismembers and hides his pieces of the old man.. As he finishes his job, the clock turns on 4. At the same time, the narrator hears a knock at the street door. The police are at the door. the neighbors had heard the shrieks of the old man and called the police office. The narrator lets the police in acting like nothing happened telling them that it was simply him yelling in his dreams. The man is careful to act cheerful and chatty in order not to look suspicious. He leads the police officers

The next trick used in this story to make it scary was the beating of the mans heart once he woke up and came to be suspicious that someone was in the room with him. The speaker describes the beating of the heart as "so strange a noise as [it] excited me to uncontrollable terror" (Poe, 3). At this point the reader may think that it is the conscious of the speaker that is really bothering him rather than the mans heartbeat. Every time the speaker refers to the heartbeat he says that it keeps getting louder and louder. One can come to the assumption that at this point the speaker is only looking for reasons to support his killing a man. And in fact it is the beating of the mans heart that drove the speaker/killer to confessing about what he has done and showing the police where the body was.

The tone of the narrative is rather mysterious which conveys an energetic and odd mood. “The Tell-Tale Heart” talks about a villain who is very disturbed by the abhorrent eye of an old man. The villain is so bothered by the atrocious eye that he convinces himself into killing the innocent old man although he delays the murder day after day because he is eager to find the most ideal time to commit the murder. Although after a seven-day wait, the villain decides to kill the old man on the eight night, and he hides the corpse of the elder under a series of floorboards in a very clever manner. Soon after, the police arrived at the house that the murder was committed in because the neighbors of the old man complained that they heard a noise coming

The narrator is concerned that someone is going to find out that he killed the old man. He finds out that the old man vexes him but more his eye. The narrator acted innocently, so the officers wouldn’t know that he was guilty. The “Tell Tale Heart” by Edgar Allan Poe is about a narrator, that convinces readers of his sanity for the murder that he commits to an old man with a vulture

Both of these tales have a narrator that gave ambiguous and shallow reason for their murders. In the Tell-Tale-Heart, it is the old man 's “eye of vulture” (1) that terrified him. The narrator liked the old man, but his eye disturbed him deeply that made him to commit the crime.

In the short story of Tell-Tale Heart, the narrator talks about an insane mad man who speaks to himself. He describes what his intentions to kill an old man who he loves, but allows his emotions to overwhelm him with the thoughts that the old man’s eye in which he identifies as a vulture’s eye is invading his every emotion. He goes on to expose his every move insanely and vividly to murder the old man.

First, horror is developed in “The Tell Tale Heart” by the insanity of the narrator. The narrator believes he is a sane person, but contradicted himself when he kills the old man. This creates a complex in the character’s mind. When the police shows because the neighbors heard a yell, he begins to hear the old man’s heartbeat, but his guilt consumes him and he confesses to murdering the old man and putting his body underneath the floorboards. Also, in the beginning of the story, the narrator describes why he wants to kill the old man. “It was impossible to say how first the idea entered my brain; but once conceived, it haunted me day and night” (Para. 2). His insane idea of killing the old man because of his vulture eye pops into his thoughts without a preconceived notion of doing so. The murder is premeditated and thought out as each night he cracks the door open and glares the lantern directly at the vulture eye. The insanity of the narrator develops “The Tell Tale Heart” into horror.

Both narrators had nonsensical motives for murdering the victim, but they were different in a few ways. In “The Tell Tale Heart,” the narrator absolutely despises the old man’s eye. When the narrator says, “Passion there was none. I loved the old man. He had never wronged me. He had never given me an insult” (105), the reader presumes that the narrator would never do anything to hurt the old man. But, the way the narrator describes the eye, “He had the eye of a vulture-a pale blue eye, with a film over it. Whenever it fell upon me, my blood ran cold” (105) shows the reader just how much the narrator hated the man’s eye. The quote also reveals to the reader a reason why the narrator could potentially do harm unto the old man. Even though the narrator had nothing against the old man except for his bothersome eye, he acted impulsively and killed the old man because he could not stand the eye any longer. Conversely, the narrator from “The Cask of Amontillado” killed the man because he hated the man. For instance the excerpt, “The thousand injuries of Fortunato I had borne as I best could, but when he ventured upon insult I vowed revenge” (75) shows that the narrator, Montresor, is planning revenge on Fortunato because of an insult he said.

The narrator can think of nothing else but killing the old man with which he lives even though he has nothing against this man and actually doesn’t mind him. He finds the man’s eye to be so repulsive that the only way to deal with it is by destroying the old man. The eye is described as resembling “that of a vulture – a pale blue eye, with a film over it.” The narrator also describes how this eye makes him feel when he states that “I grew furious as I gazed upon it. I saw it with perfect distinctness – all a dull blue, with a hideous veil that chilled the very marrow in his bones.” This startling quote helps to deepen the story’s suspense. The theme of violence is also shown when the murderer describes what he does with the old man’s body after killing him. “First of all I dismembered the corpse. I cut off the head and the arms and the legs.”

The Tell Tale Heart' is a story about a man who killed an old man just

The point of view each story is told from is a key factor to the unfolding of the events. Had they been told by an outside party rather than first hand from the men who committed the crimes, the depth of their insanity may not have been revealed. Recounted with a harsh callousness, Montresor never pauses or hesitates in his retelling. He speaks with an unnerving smoothness as if he were speaking of something far more innocuous than murder. Just the same, he would allow for no distraction from his plan. His cool manner lends itself to an eerie glimpse of his personality. No real regret is ascertainable, save for the very end when the Montresor tells us that his. The narrator of “The Tell-Tale Heart”, however, confesses his crime with an edgy nervousness. His story is choppy and disruptive. His madness has a stronger sense of urgency. His remorse for the loss of the old man can be

The story of “The Tell-Tale Heart” is suspicious and mysterious, but what really caused the narrator to kill somebody? Most people kill others because they’re either told to because someone they know is taken a hostage, or they do it just so they can blame their relatives.The narrator’s tone and mood are the ones to blame, but are the tone and mood both true or are they both lies? We may not know, but we will find the answer sooner or later.

‘The Tell Tale Heart" murder was similar; however the reasons for murder were different. The narrator, who doesn’t have a name, is a neurotic and suffers from a hypersensitive condition. In this short story, the narrator plots to kill an old man, with a vulture eye. The differences between these two murders: the victim in this case was an old man and was like a mentor to him. The narrator had a close relationship with him; they weren’t enemies or rivals as in "The Cask". The murder from the ‘The Cask, was a jealous murder. This murder was done to prove a point. "The Tell Tale" the victim (the old man), as the narrator describes, had a pale blue eye with a film over it "a dull blue, with a hideous veil over it that chilled the very marrow in my bones". As I was reading, I realized that he didn’t really have a good reason to kill the old man. It almost seemed as if he were looking for a reason to kill him. "Object there was none. Passion there was none. I loved the old man. He had never wronged me. He had never given me insult. For his gold I had no desire. I think it was his eye! Yes, it was this!" This narrator doesn’t kill his mentor, over jealousy, or insults. The narrator kills the old man because of his eyes. He doesn’t like the old man’s "vulture" eye, and it really bothered him due

Although the narrator states that he is not crazy, many people can argue that the narrator, in fact, is crazy. In the short story “The Tell-Tale Heart”, Poe uses many different types of irony to set up the narrator. In the beginning of the short story “The Tell-Tale Heart”, the narrator states, “You fancy me mad. Madmen know nothing,” (2).

The narrator in The Tell-Tale Heart is an unreliable narrator and lies often. The narrator is vexed by the old man’s eye and decides to kill him and tell the police so he can win a prize. When the police officer’s realize that the narrator is making a mockery of the old man’s death, he starts to get very anxious and agitated. The narrator in the Tell-Tale Heart is very deranged and crazy. One thing that the narrator does that makes him seem crazy is he is vexed by the old man’s eye and wants to kill him.