Why Did Lizzie Borden Kill Her Parent

In the end, people in the town seem to think that Lizzie got away with the murders and mutilations all because she was a girl. People from around the town thought for sure that she was guilty and from that point on nobody from the town accepted her. Even the judge thought that she as was a suspect and guilty, but the jury said

This is later confirmed when she threatens to “come to [them] in the black of some terrible night and … bring a pointy reckoning that will shudder” (Pg.175) Mary Warren and Betty Parris if they dare to tell the truth. This shows her determination at killing Elizabeth Proctor and securing her own reputation. Unlike many naive villains in other literatures, Abigail sets out a meticulous scheme to frame Elizabeth. First, she witnesses Mary Warren leaving a needle in a doll. Then she “[sticks] two inches [of a needle] in the flesh of her belly”(pg. 203) to frame Elizabeth of performing witchcraft. So mendacious is Abigail that she is willing to injure herself to accomplish her plan. Under her beautiful appearance also lays a manipulative heart. She is capable of manipulating not only the girls into doing things her way, but also the members of the court to her advantage. When questioned by Danforth whether the spirits she has seen are illusion, Abigail steps it up a notch by making the members of the court feel sorry for her and madly refutes, “I have been near to murdered every day because I done my duty pointing out the Devil’s people—and this is my reward? To be mistrusted, denied, questioned like a—” (Pg.210) This, following by Elizabeth's failure to tell the truth and the girl’s verisimilar acting toward the “yellow bird”, further demonstrates her manipulative power which brings the court in her favor. Altogether, many

Juliet's parents were not caring for their family. They only cared about themselves and did not take proper care of their daughter, as a result of their daughter’s death. They would ignore her at times except when they were in front of the guests. Additionally, Lady Capulet thought that Juliet grieving over her cousin’s death was foolish and made her look stupid, “Evermore weeping for your cousin’s death? What, wilt thou wash him from his grave with tears? An if thou couldst, thou couldst not make him live. Therefore, have done. Some grief shows much of love, But much of grief shows still some want of wit.” (Shakespeare.3.5.69-74). Juliet's parents were the root of Juliet's death, because of how uncaring and disregarding they were of Juliet.

“Lizzie Borden took an axe and gave her mother forty whacks. When she saw what she had done, she gave her father forty-one.” The grisly murders of Andrew and Abby Durfee Gray Borden remain to be one of the most sensational double murders in American history, rivaling even the likes of the O.J. Simpson trials. The “Lizzie Borden took an axe” rhyme is supposed to chronicle the macabre accounts of the murders. However, the rhyme possesses several historical inaccuracies. Lizzie’s “mother” in this rhyme was actually Lizzie’s stepmother and was “only” struck nineteen times with a hatchet not with an axe. Lizzie’s father, Andrew, received about ten blows to the head ( ). Though the children's rhyme is not quite historically accurate the

Abigail was a servant in Proctor´s house. Elizabeth was not a very loving woman. Proctor fell for Abigail created an affair with her. “After he had confessed it to Elizabeth, she dismissed her from her service because she did not want to tell the people in Salem that the reason was the affair between John and Abigail.” (Dulain). Abigail, Tituba and the girls went to the forest in the morning. They danced and murmured words, Abigail drank blood to curse John Proctor’s wife Elizabeth, and she would do anything to have John Proctor. Reverend Paris fond blood, Abigail and the girl’s dancing, and mercy naked. Abigail knew drinking blood is a form of witchcraft, so she tries to cover up on what they actually did in the forest. She threatens the girls to not say a word or she will harm them. "Let either of you breathe a word, or the edge of a word, about the other things, and I will come to you in the black of some terrible night and I will bring a pointy reckoning that will shudder you." (Miller)

She contrasts with Elizabeth Proctor due to her affair with John. When Elizabeth discovered the affair, she fired Abigail, who feels a strong hatred towards Elizabeth. Abigail was upset that she was fired and jealous that John had chosen Elizabeth over her, so she used her power as a juror to accuse Elizabeth by stabbing herself in the stomach with a needle and claiming that a poppet in the Proctors’ house was a voodoo doll. Elizabeth was then arrested for witchcraft. Abigail’s actions prove that she is deceitful, selfish, jealous, and vengeful.

This relates to The Crucible. Because at the end of the act two Mary Warren blamed Abigail for getting Elizabeth charged with witchcraft. Because of the doll that was planted by Abigail, Elizabeth was unfairly judged. Everyone has listened to “innocent” Abigail claims, while judging the rest of the people unfairly.

The last reason why Lizzie Borden is because she did not have a good relationship with her step-mother and didn’t consider Abby her mother. Lizzie Borden stopped calling her mother at a young age because of an affair. Although Lizzie Borden was most likely the murderer, there is still a small chance someone else was the murderer. The “Inquest Testimony of Lizzie Borden” points out,“I know of a man who has not been friendly with him. They have not been friendly for years.” Most sources said that no one had anything against Andrew Borden, but in Lizzie Borden’s testimony she says someone was not friendly with Andrew Borden and has not been for a very long time. This man that was not friendly with Andrew Borden could have been the murderer. Although there is more evidence that says Lizzie Borden is the murderer, there is still a chance that she is innocent.

Before any of the witch trials began, Abigail and her cousin Betty were in the woods with their slave Tituba. Reverend Parris, Betty’s father, found them and other girls. The next day Betty started acting strange. Reverend Parris accused Abigail of using witchcraft. Abigail turned it around, and accused Tituba and others in the town of witchcraft. That’s how everything was started. Anyone that Abigail had a grudge against would later be accused of witchcraft. Since she had a grudge about John Proctor’s wife she was Abigail’s biggest target. Now let’s talk about why she accused Elizabeth Proctor of being a witch.

The double murder of Andrew and Abby Borden still remains unsolved. The police could have done a better job investigating and the evidence showing Lizzie being linked should have been enough to charge her but this is a period of time when forensics was at its infancy and if there was no weapon there was no crime. The money involved could have brought rise to Lizzie to plot the death for inheritance. We will never

There was not enough evidence to make her guilty. According to source #1 is states that, “There was no physical evidence linking her to the murders.” There was no evidence that pointed to Lizzie, like there was no blood on her dress. Also, there was no murder weapon found in the house. There was no physical evidence that makes Lizzie the murder. The last reason Lizzie is innocent is that Andrew made many enemies that could’ve killed him. Both Andrew and Abby Borden made some enemies in their life. People said Lizzie didn’t like her stepmother, but maybe someone else didn’t like her. According to source #1 it says that, “The dour businessman had also made many enemies on his rise on the top, and rumors swirled that Andrew and Abby had perhaps been killed as revenge for Andrew’s shady business dealings.” This shows that other people could of killed Abby and Andrew. They made multiple enemies, so one of them could’ve tried to kill them. Andrew was also one of the most unpopular men in town. There could’ve been multiple people that killed Andrew and Abby besides

Another reason why it is Abigail fault is because she continued lying instead of confessing of what she did. She then gives Mary a poppet so that she can give to elizabeth so that she can be accused of stabbing and trying to kill her. Due to the actions of this elizabeth and John(husband) are in court. John later

Have you ever been so angry you thought about killing your parents with an axe? Well many people think Lizzie Borden did this exact thing. Lizzie Borden was accused of murdering her step mother and father with a hatchet on August 4, 1892. While on trial, the jury found her innocent, but many other people think her to be guilty. I think that Lizzie Borden is innocent of the murder of Andrew and Abby Borden because she loved her father, didn’t have a problem with her stepmother, and there was no physical evidence found at the crime scene. Lizzie Borden was found innocent by law, so why should it be questioned?

My opinion of Lizzie Borden’s innocence is completely reasonable in the fact that she wasn’t insane or deranged. Lizzie had a stable relationship with her stepmother and it wouldn’t cause her to murder Abby Bunfree. One reason that supports Lizzie Borden’s innocence is the fact that she loved her father and wouldn’t want to harm him and she grieved the death of her father. Although Lizzie Borden sounds like a cold blooded killer she loved her father and would hate to loose him. In the article, Lizzie Borden Case Gets New Look With Discovery of Her Lawyer’s Journals it states, “Lizzie Borden cared for her father very deeply, there was a tremendous outpouring of grief in the letter, and that’s a new side of the story.”

Lizzie’s behavior was suspicious when she was talking about her parents to the police. The author notes that “Lizzie tried purchasing poison, Prussic Acid”. Lizzie was found burning one of her dresses three days later. She said she was burning it cause it was all stained up. She yelled that someone came in and murdered her parents. How would Lizzie know if someone came in unless she seen that person or if she did it. She was also suspicious because she said all that, but there was no signs of breaking or entering into the house found out by the police. The night before the murder witnesses say that Lizzie went to a friend’s house, and she said that she thought someone was going to kill her parents. This is evidence of how she could have killed