preview

Why Did Pocahontas Saved John Smith?

Decent Essays
Open Document

From the text and documents provided, my conclusion to whether or not Pocahontas saved John Smith is that it never happened. We know from the first account about his journey to Jamestown that he indeed was there, so he was a primary source. Pieces of information I have used to make my conclusion are the two accounts of John Smith, historian Lemay's document about his opinion, and expert Lewis' interpretations about the event. After reading both of John Smith's accounts, I think that Pocahontas never saved John Smith. Both his pieces of writing give many clues to why this is true. From background information, it is known that the Virginia Company censored what writing was being sent back to Europe and England. They were instructed to write …show more content…

He claims that "In [John Smith's second version] the General History, his goal was to promote settlement in Virginia and added stories to get people interested"(Lemay, The American Dream of Captain John Smith). The main interaction with the Powhatan tribe that is described in the second account is about how he was captured and about to die. This doesn't seem like positive or stories that would make people excited to come to Virginia if they knew about the neighboring tribe which surrounds the colony being hostile. Even if young men felt like they were excited for an action thrill, their families would probably disapprove. Lemay also claims that Pocahontas pretended to save a newcomer to welcome him into the tribe, a common ritual (Lemay, The American Dream of Captain John Smith). If this ritual was so common, why isn't there any other accounts of the Powhatan tribe welcoming new settlers? No descendants of the Powhatan tribe have any knowledge of this ritual either. Overall, this source seems untrustworthy because the author of this book makes random claims and interpretations about the Powhatan tribe's traditions and rituals, and has unlikely references towards who Smith's readers were and what his writing hoped to

Get Access