preview

Why Does Hannah Accept Her Religion

Decent Essays
Open Document

Think about this- if you rejected your religion and then got stuck in a dream where everyone had that religion, would you really enjoy it anymore? I known I wouldn't. Some people believe that Hannah is starting to accept her religion, but the truth is that she's really rejecting it. It's obvious that Hannah is slowly building a bulwark between her and her religion. First of all, Hannah just hates where she is in general, which makes it worse. Of course others may believe that Hannah does like it. They may think that Hannah actually enjoys being there just because people have her religion. Some might even believe that Hannah is starting to really accept where she is. However, I believe they are looking at the picture the wrong way. Just because people have the same religion as her doesn't mean she likes where she is. This is stated clear in the book because when Hannah and Schmuel are talking about where Hannah, or, "Chaya" really lives, Hannah gets quite frustrated. "Hannah could feel her voice getting louder, like Aaron's when he was scared, and a panic feeling was gripping her chest. "New Rochelle, is, too, a city. It's in New York." …show more content…

Some are going to go against this by saying that Hannah is too young and she hasn't learned about things like that. Another reasonable response would be that Hannah is past that time. That where she is in the dream was too long ago, and things in the Jewish religion have changed since then. However, even though it was long ago, Hannah might at least know a few things about her own religion! "What's the Sherele?" Hannah had asked, showing solid proof that she wasn't interested enough to know those kinds of

Get Access