In the novel Wide Sargasso Sea by Jean Rhys and the short story “The Treatment of Bibi Haldar” by Jhumpa Lahiri, both stories manage to have many similarities. Jean Rhys and Jhumpa Lahiri write about how both characters, Antoinette and Bibi Haldar, are unaccepted by their societies. Antoinette and Bibi Haldar are misfits in their communities because they do not conform to cultural norms, their communities and peers believe they have illnesses, and both come from dysfunctional families. In Wide Sargasso Sea by Jean Rhys and the short story “The Treatment of Bibi Haldar” by Jhumpa Lahiri, both authors use the characters stories, memories, and communities’ treatment to argue that they were outcasts because of the patriarchal society they live in. In Wide Sargasso Sea, the main character is Antoinette Cosway. She is a young Creole woman who comes from a dysfunctional family. Her father, Alexander Cosway, dies before his character could be introduced. He was a former slave owner who had a plantation, Coulibri Estate, and was very wealthy. His name was tainted because his fondness of alcohol and he recklessly spent his money. People visited her father, Alexander Cosway, when he was alive, but not her or her mother, Annette. Antoinette asked her mother “why so few people came to see [them,] she told [Antoinette] that the road from Spanish Town to Coulibri Estate where [they] lived was very bad and that road repairing was now a thing of the past” (Rhys 15). In that quote,
Compare the ways in which the authors of two texts explore how society treats people who are different.
The first aspect both stories have in common is the fact that both of the women are oppressed by a man in their life.“The
The film The Sea Inside shares the heart warming real life story of a man named Ramon Sampedro. At the young age of twenty-six he suffered an accident while diving into shallow waters of the ocean that left him a quadriplegic. Now at the age of fifty-four, Ramon must depend on his family to survive. His older brother Jose, Jose’s wife, Manuela and their son Javi do their best to take care of Ramon and make him feel loved. Although Ramon is extremely grateful to his family and friends for their help all these years, he has come to see his life as aggravating and unsatisfying. He wishes to die with the little dignity he has left in his life. However, Ramon’s family is dead set against the thought of assisted suicide and the
Jean Rhys' novel Wide Sargasso Sea portrays how hair determines a crucial role in one’s status and identity through physical appearance. Hair helps provide an interpretation of a person’s complex relationships and perplexed identities. Rhys uses vivid imagery of hair as a strong representation of Antoinette’s resemblance to her mother as well as her sexual attraction towards Rochester. This strong sense of imagery is demonstrated throughout Antoinette’s imperious relationship with Rochester and her deteriorating relationship with her mother, which not only show her lacking sense of identity but also, her lack of control in relationships. Antoinette’s lost persona is constantly getting challenged due to the tension and correlation between her
While each story had their contrasting elements, the base theme of each was remarkably similar; Both of the authors manipulate the theme of motherhood to examine the ideas of slavery, home and forgiveness during two very different time periods.
being hindered by the government that they live in. In both novel’s governments the idea of
“On such a full sea” is a novel written by Chang-Rae Lee. The story is about a journey of a nineteen-year old girl name Fan. She works in the tanks diving and keeping it clean, nurturing the fish and just looking after the welfare of the fish. This is one of the most important jobs for the city of B-Mor because it is one of the major ways the city can get their revenue. They sell the fish to the Charter village. Fan’s journey starts when one-day Fan’s boyfriend Reg disappeared from B-more due to the governmental-pharmaceutical cartel she decides to leave B-Mor on the search of Reg. She explores the different social classes from the open counties, which is the low-class society and there is a high rate of crimes such as murder, robbery, and aggressive
Today I will be comparing the experiences between two young people growing up in Australia. The two stories are "The Left Hander" by Oodgeroo Noonuccal and "Destiny" by Shalini Akhil. One is about a girl who wants to become Wonder Women but she has to alternate it because she is indian (Destiny) and the other is about a girl who always used her left hand but when she was noticed to use it, she was punished(The Left Hander) . Both authors focus on two memoirs Clash of Culture and Belonging v isolation, However these have different perspectives, "The Left Hander's" Perspective is negative whereas 'Destiny' has a positive perspective. "The Left Hander's" setting is during school, the girl was just sewing in the classroom and after the teacher saw she was punished. "Destiny's" setting is at home with the persons grandma talking about an alternate way of being wonder women. Both texts
Tia represents not only herself but the general native community. They hate the Cosway widow and children because of their past slave-ownership, and despise them for their lack of wealth. Indeed, it is this hostility that motivates the natives to set Coulibri on fire and drive the Masons (now that Annette has married Mr. Mason) out of the estate.
In the novel Wide Sargasso Sea by Jean Rhys, Antoinette Mason’s identity is frequently discussed. Antoinette, the daughter of ex-slave owners and a woman whose life is dictated by mental illness, grows up in the Caribbean as a Creole during the nineteenth century. As a young adult, she is forced into a marriage with a white man from England, an event that ultimately leads Antoinette to her downfall. At the start of the novel, Antoinette and the characters around her are optimistic about their identity and future. As the plot progresses, Antoinette increasingly struggles to understand who she is and what her future entails. Ultimately, Antoinette loses her identity and her purpose. Throughout the text there are many reoccurring motifs. A motif
Authors, Jean Rhys and Charlotte Bronte constructed their novels in completely different time periods and came from different influences in writing. Jean Rhys’s fiction book, Wide Sargasso Sea is an interesting relation to Jane Eyre. The female character of Jane Eyre forms into a furiously, passionate, independent young woman. The female character of Jean Rhys’s illustration is a character that Jane will know further on as Rochester’s crazy wife who is bolted in an attic. Jean Rhys further studies this character, where as Charlotte Bronte approved that it was left explained (Thorpe 175). Antoinette, considerably like Jane, evolves in a world with minimal amount of love to offer. Both these women are taken cared of as children by
In both of these novels, which have many similar characteristics, the themes of finding identity in one’s own culture and the use of oral tradition to remain faithful to one’s heritage are
Wide Sargasso Sea by Jean Rhys shows the delicate balance between madness and sanity. Throughout both novels there is a lot of unusual behavior to say the least from Antoinette. There are many factors that can have a detrimental effect on one’s mental stability which is shown blatantly through the relationship between Antoinette and Bertha. This shows the relationship and balance between inherited factors and environmental influences such as other people and events that are happening around the person.
Gordon, Alan. "Dreams in Wide Sargasso Sea." Dreams in Wide Sargasso Sea. Victorian Web, 21 May 2004. Web. 19 Nov. 2014.
this is a dangerous place for them to be in, and that, like Eden, the