preview

Win Butler Sprawl Analysis

Decent Essays
Open Document

Arcade Fire’s Win Butler exemplifies the absence of community in sprawl when singing about The Woodlands, the infamously master-planned community he grew up in. In the song “Sprawl I (Flatlands),” he recalls trying to find “the house where [he] used to stay” amidst “towns they built to change,” evidently showing a lack of deeper connection to a childhood home. Because of sprawl’s absence of true community to associate with, both the house and the town are only transient—after all, our deepest connections to places are because of the people from those places and not the inanimate buildings. When a police officer, seeing Butler walking in the middle of night, asks him where he lives, Butler laments that he’s “been searching every corner of the earth” (Sprawl I). Clearly, sprawl’s community deficiency leaves Butler—and many others—feeling isolated and searching for a true home. Suburbia, while deeply disturbing for its suppression of community and human nature, is just as disturbing for its destruction of Mother Nature. Given sprawl’s car dependency, it is unsurprising that the outer suburbs produce the most carbon per person, in effect “[confirming] that automobile use is not only the single greatest contributor to our total carbon footprint, but also a reliable predictor of that total” (Speck …show more content…

Journalist David Owen relates that the critical suburban problem is “not the Hummer in the driveway; it’s everything else the Hummer makes possible” like the unnecessarily abundant big-box stores, the unnecessarily wide highways (built to “solve” what is often unsolvable traffic), and of course, the unnecessarily large houses (Speck 55). Reducing physical separation consequently also reduces this type of peripheral, environmentally-degrading

Get Access