preview

Worker's Compensation Case Study

Decent Essays

Worker’s Compensation: Is the Medical Assessment Tribunal’s Decision always final? Yes and No • Medical decisions are final • Non-Medical decisions can be challenged • Whether injury is a result of work or not can be challenged along with whether a claim for compensation can be made A long-standing view has been that the decisions of the independent panel of medical specialists that form the Medical Assessment Tribunal’s (MAT) cannot be challenged. However, in a recent decision by Deputy President O’Connor in the Queensland Industrial Relations Committee (QIRC) things are set to change the way Workers’ Compensation claims handled along with the implication of decisions by MAT on compensation claims. MAT has specialist expertise in assessing …show more content…

“the driver had injured his shoulder”, not “the driver had injured his shoulder because the steering wheel was defective”. This view was supported and upheld by Deputy President O’Connor. The Deputy President said that MAT’s power is to determine the “issues of a medical nature necessary to make an assessment of the claim.” The Deputy President said that MAT were expert witnesses who are asked “to provide an independent opinion based on the facts…”. Deputy President O’Connor also stated that the medical diagnosis could not be challenged but the factual and legal issues regarding the meaning of personal injury could. In other words, anything outside of the medical decision, (i.e. the injury was caused by work) can be challenged. Also, if the injury is eligible for compensation can also be challenged. Only the medical decisions of the MAT are ‘final’ such as the employee has an injury. This means that an employee’s claim for compensation could be overturned by the Employer. JJ Richards & Sons Pty Ltd v Workers’ Compensation Regulator [2016] QIRC 147 If you have an employment law or industrial relations matter, Hall Payne’s expert and award winning advice can help. Contact us via our contact page, or on 1800 659 114 for a consultation

Get Access