A company is considering two alternative investment projects both of which have a positive net present value. The projects have been ranked on the basis of both net present value (NPV) and internal rate of return (IRR). The result of the ranking is shown below: Project A Project B NPV 1st 2nd IRR 2nd 1st Discuss any four (4) potential reasons why the conflict between the NPV and IRR ranking may have arisen.

A company is considering two alternative investment projects both of which have a positive net present value. The projects have been ranked on the basis of both net present value (NPV) and internal rate of return (IRR). The result of the ranking is shown below: Project A Project B NPV 1st 2nd IRR 2nd 1st Discuss any four (4) potential reasons why the conflict between the NPV and IRR ranking may have arisen.

Intermediate Financial Management (MindTap Course List)

13th Edition

ISBN:9781337395083

Author:Eugene F. Brigham, Phillip R. Daves

Publisher:Eugene F. Brigham, Phillip R. Daves

Chapter12: Capital Budgeting: Decision Criteria

Section: Chapter Questions

Problem 11P

See similar textbooks

Similar questions

Average rate of return The following data are accumulated by Watershed Inc. in evaluating two competing capital investment proposals: Determine the expected average rate of return for each project.
A company is considering two alternative investment projects both of which have a positive net present value. The projects have been ranked on the basis of both net present value (NPV) and internal rate of return (IRR). The result of the ranking is shown below: Project A Project B NPV 1st 2nd IRR 2nd 1st Discuss any four (4) potential reasons why the conflict between the NPV and IRR ranking may have arisen B. Kumi Ltd is considering an investment in a project, which requires immediate payment of GHS15,000, followed by a further investment of GHS5,400 at the end of the first year. The subsequent return phase net cash inflows are expected to arise at the end of the following years: Year 1 2 3 4 5 Cash inflow (GHS) 6,500 7,750 5,750 4,750 3,750 You are required to estimate the internal rate of return of this project assuming the company’s cost of capital of 16%.
Comparing Investment Criteria. Define each of the following investment rules and discuss any potential shortcomings of each. In your definition, state the criterion for accepting or rejecting independent projects under each rule. a. Payback period. b. Internal rate of return. c. Profitability index. d. Net present value.
If two mutually exclusive projects were being compared, would a high cost of capital favor the longer-term or the shorter-term project? Why? If the cost of capital declined, would that lead firms to invest more in longer-term projects or shorter-term projects? Would a decline (or an increase) in the WACC cause changes in the IRR ranking of mutually exclusive projects?Note: DONOT GIVE BREIF ANSWER USE SHORT CONCEPTUAL ANSWER
I asked this question before, but for some reason, even though it was answred I cannot see it, it marks an error when I try to open it. So here it is again: Comparing Investment Criteria. Define each of the following investment rules and discuss any potential shortcomings of each. In your definition, state the criterion for accepting or rejecting independent projects under each rule. a. Payback period. b. Internal rate of return. c. Profitability index. d. Net present value. Thank you!
What are the internal rates of return (IRR) on the three projects? Does the IRR rule in this case give the same decision as NPV? How do you know? If the opportunity cost of capital is 11%, what is the profitability index for each project? Please analyze if, in general, decisions based on profitability index are consistent with decisions based on NPV. What is the most generally accepted measure to choose between the projects? Please justify your answer.
Several proposed capital projects which are economically acceptable may have to be ranked due to constraints in financial resources. In ranking these projects, the least pertinent is this statement. A. A ranking procedure on the basis of quantitative criteria may be established by specifying a minimum desired rate of return, which rate is used in calculating the net present value of each project. B. In selecting the required rate of return, one may either calculate the organization’s cost of capital or use a rate generally acceptable in the industry. C. If the internal rate of return method is used in the capital rationing problem, the higher the rate, the better the project. D. If the net present value method is used, the profitability index is calculated to rank the projects. The lower the index, the better the project.
A company is deciding whether to invest in a project. There are three possible outcomes of the investment: There is a 20% chance of the optimistic outcome, and a 65% chance of the most likely outcome arising. The expected value of profit from the project is
Internal Rate of Return is used: a) To determine the interest rate at which benefits of a project are equivalent to its costs. b) To determine which investment to choose when one of two alternatives must be chosen. c) To determine the interest rate for an investment that yields no income. d) To choose an investment that necessary to preserve the operation of the business. e) To justify a “lost-leader” project of a strategic nature.
You should accept a project when the ?: net present value is negative. profitability index is positive. payback period exceeds the required period. AAR is greater than the required return. 7. Which one of the following statements is correct? The payback period is also referred to as the benefit-cost ratio. The internal rate of return can be reliably used for all independent projects. The profitability index is used when the investment funds are limited. The net present value should not be used to rank mutually exclusive projects. 8. You should accept a project when the ?: net present value is negative. profitability index is less than 1 but greater than 0. discounted payback period is less than the required period. AAR is less than the required return. 9. The crossover point ? : is used to determine which one of two internal rates of return for a project should be used when determining if a project should be accepted. 2. is the…
A disadvantage of using the accounting rate of return to evaluate investment alternatives is that Group of answer choices A. It is superior to IRR. B. When net incomes vary from year to year, the ARR will also vary across years, making the project seem desirable in one year and not another. C. It considers the time value of money. D. It is easy to understand and it allows comparison or projects. E. Using ARR has no disadvantages.
When two mutually exclusive projects are being compared, explain whythe short-term project might be ranked higher under the NPV criterion ifthe cost of capital is high, whereas the long-term project might be deemedbetter if the cost of capital is low. Would changes in the cost of capital evercause a change in the IRR ranking of two such projects? Why or why not?