Question

Melissa and Maui purchased a brand new house. They are both very excited about decorating the
interior and the exterior of the house. Melissa plans to have everything colour coordinated. To
match the navy blue wall paint, she orders navy blue ceramic vinyl floor tiles from Ceramic Tiles
Fiji (CTF). Melissa placed an order for one hundred 30cm by 30cm navy blue ceramic vinyl square
tiles.
In order to process Melissa’s order, CTF required upfront payment of the entire contract sum of
$7,000.00. Melissa attends to the payments on 3 May 2017. The terms of the agreement stipulates:
“that the order will be processed within two weeks from the date of the receipt of full payment.
That the tiles will be delivered within two weeks from the date of receipt of full payment. It also
states that the purchaser has to exclusively engage the services of Delivery Fiji for the delivery of
tiles.”
Melissa feels it is quite unfair that they have to engage the services of Delivery Fiji and pay them
a hefty sum of $100.00 for a very small distance. Melissa wanted to make her own arrangement
for delivery at a much cheaper rate, however CTF objected to the same.
On 30th May at about 9am some orders (tiles) were ready for delivery. These tiles were for three
different buyers and one of them was Melissa. The other two buyers included one Smith and one
Misha. The Delivery Fiji delivery truck was required to attend to the loading of the tiles at 9.30am.
The tiles were packed in boxes and left at the delivery area at 9.05am with the respective buyer’s
initials and were ready to be transported to the buyers. Melissa’s navy blue tiles were packed in a
navy blue box and the box was marked with letter “M” on top. There was another light blue box
which had tiles for a different buyer Smith but it was unmarked. A purple box contained tiles for
Misha and the box was marked with letter “M” on top.
All boxes were coloured differently corresponding to the colour of the tiles in the box.
Unbeknown to CTF at about 9.30 am, an intruder went into its delivery area and loaded one navy
blue carton of tile and drove away. At that time the security officer of CTF who was supposed to
be at the delivery area was out in the parking space attending to a relative.
Delivery Fiji truck reached CTF’s delivery area at 9.50am to take delivery of all tiles. The
attending staff loaded the tiles in the delivery truck. They were provided with a list by CTF which
had the three buyers’ addresses written in different coloured ink (light blue, navy blues and purple)
corresponding to the colour of the carton of tile.
Delivery Fiji mistakenly delivers the purple coloured carton to Melissa’s residence. Melissa
acknowledges receipt by signing the delivery docket. The delivery docket had a clause which
exempted Delivery Fiji from all forms of liabilities once the goods were safely delivered to its
destination and the same was acknowledged. Melissa opened the box after two weeks when the
tile layer arrived at her place to lay the tile and, to her dismay the tiles were not what she had
ordered and expected it to be. It was not ceramic navy blue vinyl tiles instead it was plain light
blue tiles. Melisa now wishes to return the tiles to CTF and claim her money and damages. CTF
is disputing this by stating that the return of the sale period ended after 3 days from the date of
delivery.
Melissa further argues that they received a different order altogether and that CTF breached their
agreement. CTF argues that the property and risk passed to Melissa once the tiles were packed and
left at the delivery area. Melissa seeks to sue CTF and Delivery Fiji.
CTF convenes a discussion with Delivery Fiji in this respect and finds out that only two boxes
were loaded for delivery by them on that day. CTF carries out an investigation and the CCTV
footage reveals that one box was stolen from their delivery area on 30 May at about 9.30am.
Nevertheless, they still insist that they are not liable to Melissa in anyway.
Meanwhile Smith was declared a bankrupt on 2 May, 2017. Delivery Fiji had delivered the tiles
to the address provided by CTF for Smith. Smith had made an instalment of $3,000.00 and he was
supposed to pay the remaining balance of $5,000.00 to CTF upon receipt of the goods. CTF is
demanding remaining payment from Smith. CTF argues that the property and the risk passed to
Smith once the tiles were packed and left at the delivery area.
Meanwhile Misha did not receive anything and she had paid $4,000.00 as deposit and was
supposed to pay the remaining balance of $5,000.00 to CTF upon receipt of the goods.
Answer the following questions
1. Did the property and the risk indeed pass to Melissa, Smith and Misha once the goods
were left at CTF’s delivery area?
2. What remedies are available for Melissa and Misha?
3. Is Delivery Fiji liable to Melissa, Smith or Misha?
4. What remedies and defences will Delivery Fiji advance in its favour?
5. What arguments will CTF advance in its favour to dispute the various allegations
against them?

Expert Answer

Want to see the step-by-step answer?

Check out a sample Q&A here.

Want to see this answer and more?

Experts are waiting 24/7 to provide step-by-step solutions in as fast as 30 minutes!*

*Response times may vary by subject and question complexity. Median response time is 34 minutes for paid subscribers and may be longer for promotional offers.
Tagged in
Business
Accounting

Accounting For Decision Making

Related Accounting Q&A

Find answers to questions asked by students like you.

Q: Calculating contribution margin Glenn Company sells a product for $80 per unit. Variable costs are 5...

A:  

Q: Q3 Ms. Marwa started a flower shop during May 2018, Prove the accounting equation by balancing the f...

A: In the books of MS. Marwa Accounting equation Assets                        = Liabilities ...

Q: Q4Journalize the following transactions in the books of AHMED for the month of March. 2020 2020 ...

A: A journal entry is used to record the business transactions in business journal using double entry s...

Q: A profit center manager has the responsibility and authority for making decisions that affect revenu...

A: Investment turnover: This ratio gauges the operating efficiency by quantifying the amount of sales g...

Q: On June 30, 2018, Streeter Company reported the following account balances:On June 30, 2018, Princet...

A: Compute the amount of goodwill.

Q: Pimpton Plows sells its product for $50. Its variable cost per unit is $19.00. Fixed costs total $43...

A: Calculate the break even point as follows: Break even units = Fixed cost / (Selling price - variable...

Q: In profit and loss account, if debit is more than the credit, the difference is [A] net profit [B] ...

A: In profit & loss (P&L) account the difference between debit and credit balances is termed as...

Q: Draw the standard format of Cost of Goods Manufactured and Sold Statement

A: Cost of Goods manufactured is total cost of goods which are manufactured in the factory. Prime cost ...

Q: Ripley Corporation’s accumulated depreciation—furniture account increased by $7,070, while $2,520 of...

A: Formulas:

Q: Which one is more appropriate for cost of retained earning? A. Weighted Average cost of capital ...

A: Every business organization retains some part of profits for future expansion of the business. Cost ...

Q: windaer Lomparry buyan speratiuma un Jeruary 1, 2018. and uaa the everupe-coat muthud of pris ng ime...

A: Under average cost method, Inventory is valued at average cost. Under FIFO method, inventory is cons...

Q: Preparing an operating budget——sales budget Brown Company manufacture luggage sets Brown sells its l...

A: Budget:   It is a statement of estimated revenues and expenses of an organization for a specific per...

Q: Analyzing profitability analysis, service company Burlington Internet Services is an Internet servic...

A: Contribution margin per customer = Total Contribution margin / Number of customers Contribution marg...

Q: windeur Co. purdiad cyuipmenL fu ao.uD wlist a alimslad lu hurs e uaclul ile uf 10 yeara wilh sulvug...

A: Annual depreciation = (cost of the assets - residual value)/ Life of the assets = (535600-10800)/10 ...

Q: Find out the amount of bills matured during the year on the basis ofinformation given below ;Bills p...

A: Liabilities: The claims creditors have over assets or resources of a company are referred to as liab...

Q: Computing contribution margin in total, per unit, and as a ratio Complete the table below for the mi...

A: Variable cost per unit = Sales price per unit - Contribution margin per unit  = 250 - 125 = $125 Tot...

Q: Computing degree of operating leverage Following is the income statement for Marrow Mufflers for the...

A: Formulas: Degree of operating leverage = Contribution margin / Operating income Percentage change in...

Q: Mel Snow is the manager of a firm, Taxation Matters, which specialises in the preparationof income t...

A: ABC (Activity based costing) framework was created to manage the drawbacks of customary costing fram...

Q: Using variable and absorption costing, making decisions The 2018 data that follow pertain to Eli’s E...

A: Click to see the answer

Q: Using sensitivity analysis Mi Tierra Driving School charges $680 per student to prepare and administ...

A: Introduction Following formulas are used for calculation of contribution and break even point. Cont...

Q: KMC Manufacturing Company makes garden and lawn equipment. The company operates through three divisi...

A: Contribution margin:   Contribution margin refers to the process or theory that is used to judge the...

Q: Having issue with this problem. Thank you

A: Number of Outstanding stock = Number of Stocks Issued - Treasury Stock    Treasury stock is the stoc...

Q: Mr. Bailey has prepared the following divisional income statement for you to review, assuming no tra...

A: Audit division refers to advisory and independent body that tries to improve the operations of organ...

Q: Computing breakeven sales No Slip Co. produces sports socks. The company has fixed costs of $91,080 ...

A: 1. Contribution margin per package = Sale price per package  - Variable cost per package = $1.80-$0....

Q: The following is the description of cash disbursements system of Two Symbols Limited:Upon receipt of...

A: While talking about Internal control system of an organization, we refer to the set of pre-determine...

Q: . Write in detail the possible causes of each of the following variance.   Direct materials price ...

A: Variances: A cost variance is a difference between the actual expenses incurred and the standard exp...

Q: Oakland Ltd, whose capital consisted of $50000 in fully paid shares, was wound up as a result of a c...

A: As per the rule, the time a company is liquidated, its debt is paid in a defined order. The creditor...

Q: Mr Amjad is planning to start a business. He follows various accounting concepts and conventions whi...

A: Revenue recognition: Revenue recognition refers to an accounting principle which outlines the specif...

Q: BOR CPAs, Inc. is a closely held corporation owned by three stockholders who used the initials of th...

A: Payroll expense is the amount of salaries and wages paid to employees in exchange for services rende...

Q: Preparing an operating budget—sales budget; inventory, purchases and COGS budget and S&A expense...

A: Calculation of sales budget for April and May 2018:   Sales in April = $ 160000 Sales in May = Sales...

Q: Preparing an operating budget——direct labor budget Baker Company expects to produce 2,050 units in J...

A: Direct labor budget: A direct labor budget demonstrates the direct labor hours and its associated co...

Q: Sole Purpose Shoe Company is owned and operated by Sarah Charles. The company manufactures casual sh...

A: Variance analysis is an analysis used to recognize the difference between actual behavior and planne...

Q: Analyzing costs of quality Stella, Inc. is using, a costs-of-quality approach to evaluate design eng...

A: 1.  

Q: RCK Ltd issues a prospectus inviting the public to subscribe for 90 million ordinary shares of $2.00...

A: Journal entries are the transactions that are recorded in the primary book. They are chronological i...

Q: Sarah has learned a lot from you over the past two months, and has compiled the following data for S...

A: Budget Performance Report means comparing the planned budget with the actual performance.

Q: Giant Equipment Ltd. is considering two projects to invest next year. Both projects have the samesta...

A: a) In order to choose between the projects we need to consider which project has better discounted c...

Q: Question 2:Journalize the transactions of January 2020 using appropriate format.   Mr. Rasool starte...

A: Journal entries of January 2020.  

Q: Harvatin Group reported net income totaling $1,000,000 for the year 2006. The following is EXERCISE ...

A: Comprehensive Income:   The change that occurs in equity of a company from other events, transactio...

Q: Jaya, Kirti, Ekta and Shewata are partners in a firm sharing profits and losses in the ratio of 2 : ...

A: New Ratio of Kirti, Ekta and Shewata =1 : 1 : 1 Gaining Share = New Share – Old Share Kriti’s Gainin...

Q: Explain the statement: “Receipt and Payment Account is a summarisedversion of Cash Book”.

A: Receipts and payment account is a real account. It records all the cash and bank transactions made d...

Q: buestion 0 The folowing information was disdosed during the audit of Kingbird Inc. Amount Due per Ta...

A: a) Calculate the taxable income (income before income taxes) for the year 2021 as follows: The taxa...

Q: On 1 July 2015, Tiger Ltd leased a PET Injection machine from Ibri City Ltd. The machine cost Ibri C...

A: Lease: The term lease refers to an agreement where the owner of an asset gives the user an asset to ...

Q: Having issue with this problem. Thank you

A: Calculate the value of land at the date of stock issue.

Q: Name five common major classes of operating cash receipts or operating cash payments presented on th...

A: Statement of cash flows: It is one of the financial statement that shows the cash and cash equivalen...

Q: Barkers Baked Goods purchases dog treats from a supplier on February 2 at a quantity of 12,000 treat...

A: Total sales value = 12000 treats x $3 per treat = $36,000 Amount of Short term Note payable = $36,00...