Identify Ybor's expected payout ratio, the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) before the break, and the WACC percentage after the break. How large should Ybor's capital budget be for the year?  Which project(s) can be accepted?  (Refer to the Optimal Capital Budget under Key Outputs.) Assume that Ybor's management is considering a change in the firm's capital structure to include more debt.  Management would therefore like to analyze the effects of an increase in the debt ratio to 60%.  The treasurer believes that such a move would cause lenders to increase the required rate of return on new bonds (rd) to 12% and that cost of equity (rs)would rise to 14.5%.  Explain how this change affects the optimal capital budget.  Which project(s) can be accepted?  (Refer to the Optimal Capital Budget under Key Outputs.)

Cornerstones of Cost Management (Cornerstones Series)
4th Edition
ISBN:9781305970663
Author:Don R. Hansen, Maryanne M. Mowen
Publisher:Don R. Hansen, Maryanne M. Mowen
Chapter20: Inventory Management: Economic Order Quantity, Jit, And The Theory Of Constraints
Section: Chapter Questions
Problem 12DQ
icon
Related questions
Question

Percentages need to be entered in decimal format, for instance 3% would be entered as .03.

Ybor City Tobacco Company has for many years enjoyed a moderate, but stable growth in sales and earnings.  In recent times, however, cigar consumption and consequently Ybor's sales have been falling, primarily because of the public's greater awareness of the health dangers associated with smoking.  Anticipating further declines in tobacco sales in the future, Ybor's management hopes eventually to move almost entirely out of the tobacco business and into a newly developed, diversified product line in growth-oriented industries.  The company is especially interested in the prospects of pollution-control devices, because its research department has already done much work on the problems of filtering smoke.  Right now, the company estimates that an investment of $15 million will be necessary to purchase new facilities and to begin production of these products, but the investment could earn a return of about 18% within a short time.  The only other available investment opportunity costs $6 million and is expected to return about 10.4%.  

The company is expected to pay a $3.00 dividend on its three million outstanding shares, the same as its dividend last year.  The directors could be persuaded to change the dividend if there are good reasons for doing so.  Total earning after taxes for the year are expected to be $14.25 million; the common stock is currently selling for $56.25 per share; the firm's target debt/assets ratio is 45%; and its marginal tax rate is 40%.  The costs of various forms of financing are as follows:  (This information is shown on the spreadsheet provided.)

  • New bonds, rd = 11% (the before-tax rate)
  • New common stock sold at $56.25 per share will net $51.25
  • Required rate of return on retained earnings (cost of equity), rs =14%
  1. Identify Ybor's expected payout ratio, the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) before the break, and the WACC percentage after the break.
  2. How large should Ybor's capital budget be for the year?  Which project(s) can be accepted?  (Refer to the Optimal Capital Budget under Key Outputs.)
  3. Assume that Ybor's management is considering a change in the firm's capital structure to include more debt.  Management would therefore like to analyze the effects of an increase in the debt ratio to 60%.  The treasurer believes that such a move would cause lenders to increase the required rate of return on new bonds (rd) to 12% and that cost of equity (rs)would rise to 14.5%.  Explain how this change affects the optimal capital budget.  Which project(s) can be accepted?  (Refer to the Optimal Capital Budget under Key Outputs.) 
  4. Considering the information presented in Question 3, if rs rose to 16%, would the low-return project be acceptable?  (Refer to the Optimal Capital Budget under Key Outputs.)
  5. Considering the information presented in Question 4, would the project selection be affected if the proposed dividend was eliminated ($0)?  (Refer to the Optimal Capital Budget under Key Outputs.)
1. There are a number of instructions with which you should be familiar to use these
computerized models. These instructions appear in a separate worksheet labeled
INSTRUCTIONS. If you have not already done so, you should read these instructions now. To
read these instructions, click on the worksheet labeled INSTRUCTIONS.
2. Only two projects can be analyzed with this model, and those projects must be entered in
order of higher IRR first and the lower IRR next.
3. The easiest way to work on this problem is to make the required changes in the input
section, observe the change in yield, record the change, and then answer the questions as
required.
INPUT DATA:
KEY OUTPUTS:
$3.00
$3.00
Previous dividend:
Expected payout:
63.16%
Proposed dividend:
Shares outstanding:
Earnings:
Current stock price:
WACC before break:
10.67%
WACC after break:
10.96%
3,000,000
$14,250,000
$56.25
Break point with $3 div:
Break point with $0 div:
$9,545,455
$25,909,091
Debt ratio:
45.00%
Cost of new debt, rd:
11.00%
Optimal capital budget:
Project
$51.25
Net price new stock
Cost of equity, rs
IRR
Cost
$15,000,000
$0
14.00%
1
18.00%
Tax rate:
40.00%
0.00%
Total capital budget
$15,000,000
Project
Cost
IRR
Cum. Cost
$15,000,000
$6,000,000
$21,000,000
$15,000,000
$21,000,000
1
18.00%
10.40%
Total
MODEL-GENERATED DATA:
With proposed dividend:
Earnings
14,250,000
(000וב )
5,250,000
Dividend
Retained earnings
Borrow
4,295,455
Financing before break
9,545,455
Marginal cost of capital up to break point:
After-Tax
Weighted
Cost
Component
Debt
Percent
Cost
45%
0.0660
0.0297
RE
55%
0.1400
0.0770
0.1067
Marginal cost of capital above break point:
After-Tax
Weighted
Component
Debt
Percent
Cost
Cost
45%
0.0660
0.0297
RE
55%
0.1452
0.0799
0.1096
Capital cost:
Capital cost
10.67%
Range of financing
1
9,545,455
9,545,456
50,000,000
10.67%
10.96%
10.96%
Optimal capital budget:
Project
IRR
Cost
1
18.00%
15,000,000
0.00%
15,000,000
Transcribed Image Text:1. There are a number of instructions with which you should be familiar to use these computerized models. These instructions appear in a separate worksheet labeled INSTRUCTIONS. If you have not already done so, you should read these instructions now. To read these instructions, click on the worksheet labeled INSTRUCTIONS. 2. Only two projects can be analyzed with this model, and those projects must be entered in order of higher IRR first and the lower IRR next. 3. The easiest way to work on this problem is to make the required changes in the input section, observe the change in yield, record the change, and then answer the questions as required. INPUT DATA: KEY OUTPUTS: $3.00 $3.00 Previous dividend: Expected payout: 63.16% Proposed dividend: Shares outstanding: Earnings: Current stock price: WACC before break: 10.67% WACC after break: 10.96% 3,000,000 $14,250,000 $56.25 Break point with $3 div: Break point with $0 div: $9,545,455 $25,909,091 Debt ratio: 45.00% Cost of new debt, rd: 11.00% Optimal capital budget: Project $51.25 Net price new stock Cost of equity, rs IRR Cost $15,000,000 $0 14.00% 1 18.00% Tax rate: 40.00% 0.00% Total capital budget $15,000,000 Project Cost IRR Cum. Cost $15,000,000 $6,000,000 $21,000,000 $15,000,000 $21,000,000 1 18.00% 10.40% Total MODEL-GENERATED DATA: With proposed dividend: Earnings 14,250,000 (000וב ) 5,250,000 Dividend Retained earnings Borrow 4,295,455 Financing before break 9,545,455 Marginal cost of capital up to break point: After-Tax Weighted Cost Component Debt Percent Cost 45% 0.0660 0.0297 RE 55% 0.1400 0.0770 0.1067 Marginal cost of capital above break point: After-Tax Weighted Component Debt Percent Cost Cost 45% 0.0660 0.0297 RE 55% 0.1452 0.0799 0.1096 Capital cost: Capital cost 10.67% Range of financing 1 9,545,455 9,545,456 50,000,000 10.67% 10.96% 10.96% Optimal capital budget: Project IRR Cost 1 18.00% 15,000,000 0.00% 15,000,000
Expert Solution
trending now

Trending now

This is a popular solution!

steps

Step by step

Solved in 2 steps

Blurred answer
Knowledge Booster
Rate Of Return
Learn more about
Need a deep-dive on the concept behind this application? Look no further. Learn more about this topic, finance and related others by exploring similar questions and additional content below.
Similar questions
  • SEE MORE QUESTIONS
Recommended textbooks for you
Cornerstones of Cost Management (Cornerstones Ser…
Cornerstones of Cost Management (Cornerstones Ser…
Accounting
ISBN:
9781305970663
Author:
Don R. Hansen, Maryanne M. Mowen
Publisher:
Cengage Learning