Review Question 17.1 To decide whether an object is electrically charged, we need to observe its repulsion from some other objects, not its attraction. Why is attraction insufficient?
The reason behind attraction being an insufficient condition for deciding whether an object is electrically charged or not.
Answer to Problem 1RQ
Solution:
Attraction can exist between a charged and a neutral object also, due to the charging by induction. So, attraction is not sufficient to decide whether the object is charged or not. Repulsion cannot exist because of an induced charge so repulsion is a sufficient condition.
Explanation of Solution
Introduction:
There are various methods of charging an object, such as charging by friction, charging by induction, charging by conduction, and grounding.
Charging by induction is the method in which a neutral object is placed near the charged object and since there are electrons and protons in every atom of an object, they will either attract or repel each other. So, the positive (protons) and negative (electrons) charges that make a nucleus neutral, are separated by the presence of an external charged object. So, on one side there will be negatively charged electrons and on the other side there will be positively charged protons. This is called polarization of the object. The sides near the object of known charge (assume positive) will be of the opposite charge (negative) and vice versa. Neutral objects are attracted towards the charged object irrespective of the fact whether the charge is positive or negative.
Explanation:
Suppose a positively charged object is placed near a metal piece. Since electrons are loosely bound in the atoms of metals, electrons will move towards the face that is near the positively charged object. When electron leaves the atom, the atom will get positively charged. Since the face with the negative charge is near the positively charged object, the metal piece will be attracted towards the positively charged object.
To decide whether an object is electrically charged or not, the object needs to be placed near another object of known charge. If it is repelled by the object, then the first object could be of positive or negative charge. But, if the two objects are attracted to each other, it is not sufficient to decide because a charged object can induce a charge of the opposite sign on the neutral object. It means that the attraction between the objects can exist due to an induced charge. Thus, it will not be possible to decide whether the object was charged prior to the process, or charge has been induced by the second object.
Conclusion:
Therefore, repulsion is a sufficient condition for deciding whether an object is electrically charged or not.
Want to see more full solutions like this?
Chapter 17 Solutions
College Physics
Additional Science Textbook Solutions
Introduction to Electrodynamics
Conceptual Physical Science (6th Edition)
Conceptual Integrated Science
The Cosmic Perspective (8th Edition)
Modern Physics
Applied Physics (11th Edition)
- An object with negative charge is placed in a region of space where the electric field is directed vertically upward. What is the direction of the electric force exerted on this charge? (a) It is up. (b) It is down. (c) There is no force. (d) The force can be in any direction.arrow_forwardIf you have charged an electroscope by contact with a positively charged object, describe how you could use it to determine the charge of other objects. Specifically, what would the leaves of the electroscope do if other charged objects were brought near its knob?arrow_forwardBare free charges do not remain stationary when close together. To illustrate this, calculate the acceleration of two isolated protons separated by 2.00 nm (a typical distance between gas atoms). Explicitly show how you follow the steps in the Problem-Solving Strategy for electrostatics.arrow_forward
- Compare and contrast the Coulomb force field and the electric field. To do this, make a list of five properties for the Coulomb force field analogous to the five properties listed for electric field lines. Compare each item in your list of Coulomb force field properties with those of the electric field—are they the same or different? (For example, electric field lines cannot cross. Is the same true for Coulomb field lines?)arrow_forwardIntegrated Concepts An electron has an initial velocity of 5.00106m/s in a uniform 2.00105N/C strength electric field. the field accelerates the electron in the direction opposite to its initial velocity. (a) What is the direction of the electric field? (b) How far does the electron travel before coming to rest? (c) How long does it take the electron to come to rest? (d) What is the electron’s velocity when it returns to its starting point?arrow_forwardElectric charge can accumulate on an airplane in flight. You may have observed needle-shaped metal extensions on the wing tips and tail of an airplane. Their purpose is to allow charge to leak off before much of it accumulates. The electric field around the needle is much larger than the field around the body of the airplane and can become large enough to produce dielectric breakdown of the air, discharging the airplane. To model this process, assume two charged spherical conductors are connected by a long conducting wire and a 1.20-C charge is placed on the combination. One sphere, representing the body of the airplane, has a radius of 6.00 cm; the other, representing the tip of the needle, has a radius of 2.00 cm. (a) What is the electric potential of each sphere? (b) What is the electric field at the surface of each sphere?arrow_forward
- There are very large numbers of charged particles in most objects. Why, then, don't most objects exhibit static electricity?arrow_forwardUnreasonable Results 64. (a) Calculate the electric field strength near a 10.0 cm diameter conducting sphere that has 1.00 C of excess charge on it. (b) What is unreasonable about this result? (c) Which assumptions are responsible?arrow_forwardA test charge of +2C is placed halfway between a charge of +6 C and another of +4 /C separated by 10 cm. (a) What is the magnitude of the force on the test charge? (b) What is the direction of this force (away from or toward the +6 C charge)?arrow_forward
- Calculate the initial (from rest) acceleration of a proton in a 5.00X106 N/C electric field (such as created by a research Van de Graaff). ). Explicitly show how you follow the steps in the Problem-Solving Strategy for electrostatics.arrow_forwardConstruct Your Own Problem Consider identical spherical conducting space ships in deep space where gravitational fields from other bodies are negligible compared to the gravitational attraction between the ships. Construct a problem in which you place identical excess charges on the space ships to exactly counter their gravitational attraction. Calculate the amount of excess charge needed. Examine whether that charge depends on the distance between the centers of the ships, the masses of the ships, or any other factors. Discuss whether this would be an easy, difficult, or even impossible thing to do in practice.arrow_forwardA large charge +Q and a small charge q are a short distance apart. How do the electric forces on each charge compare? Is this comparison described by another physical law? (Hint: See Chapter 3.4.)arrow_forward
- Physics for Scientists and Engineers: Foundations...PhysicsISBN:9781133939146Author:Katz, Debora M.Publisher:Cengage LearningPhysics for Scientists and Engineers, Technology ...PhysicsISBN:9781305116399Author:Raymond A. Serway, John W. JewettPublisher:Cengage LearningPrinciples of Physics: A Calculus-Based TextPhysicsISBN:9781133104261Author:Raymond A. Serway, John W. JewettPublisher:Cengage Learning
- College PhysicsPhysicsISBN:9781938168000Author:Paul Peter Urone, Roger HinrichsPublisher:OpenStax CollegeAn Introduction to Physical SciencePhysicsISBN:9781305079137Author:James Shipman, Jerry D. Wilson, Charles A. Higgins, Omar TorresPublisher:Cengage Learning